ANNUAL REPORT OF THE STANDING COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

JANUARY – DECEMBER 2005

Name of the Committee: Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Chairperson: Mr F Beukman, NNP 31 January 2005 – 14 September 2005

Mr T Godi, PAC 01 November 2005 – to date

Committee Secretaries: Ms N Madide

Mr E Molefe – Resigned 31 March 2005

Mr G Dixon

Chairperson’s overview:

The Standing Committee on Public Accounts (SCOPA) continued to discharge its responsibilities within the scope of its mandate.

Throughout the year and in all its work SCOPA was guided by its self-declared goals, viz:

I. Covering a greater volume of work

II. Strengthening the qualitative aspect of its work

III. Increasing the assertiveness of follow-up actions where corrective measures have been recommended.

IV. Creatively influencing improvements of financial management in the public sector.

These goals SCOPA endeavored to live up to, to the best of its ability within the constraints of organizational capacity and time.

SCOPA remains indebted to its experienced and dependable support staff; unfilled vacancies notwithstanding. The support of the Auditor-General’s office remains solid, crucial and welcome. It, together with that of other stakeholders, can only be improved.

The committee continued with its basic operational structure of two working groups and a plenary. The two SCOPA groups were ably led by Honourable P. Gerber and Honourable L. Mabe (who was later in the year replaced by Honourable L. Mashiane)

The committee as usual, held numerous public hearings of Departments and Public Entities whose state of affairs so warranted and sent questions for clarity to others.

It is our conviction that the Committee can and actually must improve on smarter ways of discharging of its workload.

The floor-crossing window brought some substantive changes in the composition of the committee and some how disrupted its activities with negative consequences.

The committee undertook two international study tours to Mozambique and Australia. Both tours were important milestones in sharing experiences, ideas and approaches with counterparts from these countries. Committee members were positively and greatly capacitated by these visits

The Committee; however; did not have provincial oversight visits, a situation that we believe will be rectified.

Thanks to the office of the Auditor-General the committee had an opportunity to meet and exchange views and experiences with the Auditors-General of the United Kingdom and Malaysia.

SCOPA, as a learning organisation, will sum up 2005’s experiences to inform and improve its work in 2006.

Vision and mission of the committee

Mission

Guided by the Constitution and the rules of Parliament, SCOPA will promote effective and efficient financial management of, and the accountability for, all matters concerning public finance. To this end it will exercise a rigorous oversight role to ensure maximum value for each taxpayer Rand in such a way that it contributes towards the improvement in the quality of life of all South Africans.

Goals

For SCOPA to earnestly pursue its MISSION this year, it has as its four overriding goals:

· To cover a greater volume of work which is of relevance to its MISSION. This in terms of the number of state related bodies and finance-related issues it actively exercises oversight over.

· To strengthen the qualitative aspects of its investigative work. This is in order to more fully understand and more fully respond to existing areas of financial management weakness and under-performance.

· To increase the consistency, regularity and assertiveness of follow-up actions where corrective action has been deemed necessary.

· To more assertively and creatively influence improvements in financial management, wherever this might be necessary in the broader public sector.

List of public entities over which the committee exercise oversight

Please see APPENDIX I

Number of meetings held and those cancelled

MEETINGS OF SCOPA 2005

Meeting	Group 1	Group 2	Plenary

No of Meetings held	25	16	21

Cancellations	----	04	01

PLENARY MEETING BREAKDOWN

Admin	05

Group 1 Hearing	06

Group 2 Hearing	10

Legislation referred to the committee (Finalised and not finalised): indicate the following:-

No Legislation was referred to the SCOPA for 2005

Papers (International Agreements, Protocols, Reports etc) referred to the Committee: indicate the following: -

No papers or International Agreements were referred to the SCOPA for 2005. Please see APPENDIX I for a list of Annual Reports of Public Entities the Committee oversees and No 11: Annual Reports of the Executive, page 8 below for further information.

Oversight (Local) visits

No oversight visits were conducted by the committee for 2005

International Visits:

12.1 AUSTRALIAN COUNCIL OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEES (ACPAC)

· Objectives of each trip

The Standing Committee on Public Accounts (SCOPA) was invited by the Australasian Council of Public Accounts Committees (ACPAC) to participate at a Conference that took place from 6 to 8 February 2005, at Parliament House, Brisbane, Australia. The main theme of the Conference was “Current Challenges Facing Public Accounts Committees”.

The delegation gained profound insight into the common challenges facing most Public Accounts Committees. In this regard the following observations were made:

a) The increasing need to encourage internal Auditing in the public sector and to implement effective risk management strategies. Risk management is an essential component of good corporate governance and Audit Committee can play an important role in ensuring that risk management is prioritized.

b) The need to strengthen forensic auditing. The Office of the Auditor General to play a prominent role in this regard.

c) Public Accounts Committees to encourage government departments to move away from Cash Basis to Accrual Accounting. Accrual accounting is more desirable because it records all transactions when they occur and not when they are paid for as in cash basis of accounting. Therefore the consumption of resources represents the true state of equity available in government.

d) Public Accounts Committees should encourage performance auditing to ensure good value for money. The goal of the performance auditing would be to improve programs and operations, saving taxpayers money, providing better services to the public and obtaining the best value for money. However, the initiative is faced with a number of challenges. The major constraint being the lack of funds and sufficient personnel at the office of the Auditor General.

e) The need to fight corruption in the Public Sector by promoting openness and transparency. There was an agreement that corruption thrives in environment of secrecy.

f) Research capacity to assist the PAC Committees in holding the government departments accountable.

g) Enhance accountability by placing Parliament at the centrer of the accountability chain. Such accountability has a number of facets, one of which is the executive being answerable to Parliament for its use of public resources.

h) The need to track and make follow-ups on implementation of PAC recommendations.

i) Public Accounts Committees to have access to information and powers to make enquiries and taking evidence.

j) The need to look into the issue of constitutionalsing the powers of the Public Accounts Committees. This means that the powers of the PAC should be guaranteed in the Constitutions of countries and states/provinces.

· Dates

6 to 8 February 2005

· Delegation

African National Congress

Mr PJA Gerber

Mr RS Ndou

Ms TV Tobias

Democratic Alliance

Dr SM Van Dyk

Committee Secretary accompanying the Delegation

Mr L Pakati

· Country, places visited

Parliament House, Brisbane, Australia

· Report (when was it adopted)

Wednesday, 14 September 2005

· Report publication (ATC date), if not published why?

Published in ATC Wednesday, 12 October 2005

· Debate in the House

Adopted in NA Minutes 16 November 2005

12.2 MOZAMBIQUE STUDY TOUR

· Objectives of each trip

The Standing Committee on Public Accounts undertook a study tour to the Mozambique Parliament. The purpose of the study tour was to obtain insight into the procedural operations of the Public Accounts committee and the Finance committee in the execution of their oversight of public finance management.

It was also our intention to gain an understanding of the audit process followed in Mozambique. In our interaction we sought to determine the style, approach and methodology of their engagement with the executive, their system of dealing with and prioritization of audit reports and their progress in performance auditing.

The Administrative Tribunal’s role has a number of advantages in terms of oversight.

a) It is equipped with the legal framework to assess financial statements,

b) Investigate maladministration and

c) Prosecute offenders.

The Administrative Tribunal gives the exercise of overseeing the expenditure of public finances the power to enforce its findings and resolutions. The Auditor-General system and the court system have strengths and weaknesses that should be discussed. The major shortcoming of the court system is that there is a distance between the interaction of the Planning and Budget committee and the Administrative Tribunal.

The Planning and Budget Committee proposed further interaction with SCOPA at the Southern African Development Community Organisation of Public Accounts Committees (SADCOPAC) level. It is in favour of brainstorming the most suitable system for oversight of public finances in Southern Africa.

· Dates

31 July 2005 – 03 August 2005

· Delegation

African National Congress

Dr G Koornhof
Mr D Gumede

Ms L Mabe

Mr R Mofokeng

Ms L Mashiane

Democratic Alliance

Ms A Dreyer

United Democratic Movement

Mr G Madikiza

United Christian Democratic Movement

Mr B Pule

Committee Secretary accompanying the Delegation

Mr G Dixon

Office of the Auditor-General

Ms N Hlasa

Ms Z Keto

· Country, places visited

Mozambique Parliament, Maputo,

· Report (when was it adopted)

Wednesday, 09 November 2005

· Report publication (ATC date), if not published why?

Published in ATC Monday, 14 November 2005

· Debate in the House

Debate still pending

Budget Vote: Not Applicable to SCOPA

Annual Reports of the Executive (30 September 2004)

· Public Hearings: if not held why

The Committee is not able to conduct public hearings on all the Annual Reports tabled. It has devised a system, captured in the 16^th report of SCOPA 2003[g1] , to prioritise all the reports according to agreed upon criteria. A Category A classification denotes issues that require a public hearing. The matters in these reports are judged according to the following criteria:

- The audit opinion on votes and public entities is adverse, disclaimed or qualified.

- Special reports of the Auditor-General.

- Highly inadequate tabled responses to SCOPA recommendations.

- Matters of serious public concern not reported on by the Auditor-General.

- Size of budget and/or assets.

- Unqualified reports with material losses, cases of misconduct, and/or fruitless or unauthorized expenditure.

The Committee identified 34 departments and entities that required further public scrutiny. It was only able to conduct 16 Public Hearings of the 34 identified. The time constraints of the Parliamentary calendar forced the Committee to prioritise the hearings and schedule them accordingly. The 18 departments and entities that did not appear will be reassessed according to their 2004/05 financial statements.

Group 1 Review of Annual Report Financial Statements 2003-2004

Report Name	Report Tabled	Category adopted by group	Hearing	Resolution adopted by Plenary	Resolution tabled (ATC) 2003/04 in 2005
Annual report of the Auditor-General
AGRICULTURE	30-09-2004	B
Agriculture - Unauthorised expenditure
Agricultura Credit account (part of vote report)
Agricultural Research Council
Bala Farms	08-09-2004	B
Inala Farms
Land and Agricultural bank of SA	31-08-2004	A		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
National Agricultural Marketing Council	15-09-2004	B
Ncera Farms (Pty) Limited	20-09-2004	B
Ondersterpoort Biological Product Limited	15-09-2004	B
Perishable products export control board	15-09-2004	B
SA Vetinary Council	19-09-2004	C		14-09-2005	12-10-2005

COMMUNICATION	13-10-2004
Communication - Unauthorised expenditure
ICASA	01-09-2004	B		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
SA Post Office	10-11-2004
SABC	14-09-2004	C		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
SENTECH	01-09-2004	B
Telkom	14-09-2004
Universal Service Agency	30-09-2005
Universal Service Fund	30-09-2005
Woordeboek van die Afrikaanse Taal

DEFENCE	02-09-2004	A		08-06-2005	02-08-2005
Defence - Unauthorised expenditure
Armaments Corporation of South Africa (ARMSCOR)	18-08-2004	B
Castle Control Board
Special Defence Account		B

ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS AND TOURISM	01-09-2004	B
Environmental Affairs and Tourism - Unauthorised expenditure
Greater St Lucia Wetland Park Authority	31-08-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Johannesburg World Summit	12-08-2005
Marine Living Resources Fund
National Botanical Institute	25-08-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
South African National Parks	01-09-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
South African Tourism Board	01-09-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
South African Weather Service	17-01-2005	B

FOREIGN AFFAIRS	20-10-2004	B
Foreign Affairs - Unauthorised expenditure

LABOUR	31-08-2004	B
Labour - Unauthorised expenditure
Banking SETA	26-08-2004	B		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Chemical Industries Education and Training Authority	27-08-2004	B		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Clothing, textile, footwear, and leather SETA	27-08-2004	C		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration	08-09-2004
Compensation Commissioner	31-08-2004
Construction Education and Training Authority	02-09-2004	B
Diplomacy, Intelligence, Defence and Trade SETA	08-09-2004	B		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Employment's Condition Commission
Energy SETA	01-09-2004	B		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
ETDP, SETA	27-08-2004	B		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Financial and Accounting SETA	27-08-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Food and Beverages SETA	27-08-2004	B		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Forest Industries SETA	27-08-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Health and Welfare SETA	27-08-2004	B		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Information Systems Electronic & Telecommunications Technologies SETA	27-08-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Insurance SETA	26-08-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Local Government, Water and Related Services SETA	27-08-2004	B		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
Manufacturing Engineering and Related SETA	27-08-2004	B
Media, Advertising, Publishing, Printing&Packaging SETA	27-08-2004	B		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Mining Qualifications Authority	27-08-2004
National Economic Development & Labour Council	08-10-2004
National Productivity Institute
National Productivity Institute	26-08-2004
Police, Private Security, Legal and Correctional Services SETA	27-08-2004	C		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
Primary Agricultural SETA	27-08-2004	C		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
Secondary Agriculture SETA	27-08-2004	B		21-06-2005
Services SETA	26-08-2004	C		21-06-2005
Sheltered Factory
Tourism, Hospitality and Sport SETA	27-08-2004	B		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Transport SETA	27-08-2004	B		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Umsobomvu Youth Fund
Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF)	31-08-2004	A		08-06-2005	02-08-2005
Wholesale & Retail Services Seta	27-08-2004	B		21-06-2005

LAND AFFAIRS	30-09-2004	B
Land Affairs - Unauthorised expenditure
Commission on Restitution of Land Rights	30-05-2005
Registration of Deeds Trading Account
Ingonyama Trust Board	15-09-2004	A	13-04-2005	30-08-2005

MINERALS AND ENERGY	30-09-2004
Minerals and Energy - Unauthorised expenditure
Central Energy Fund, Petro SA, SFF Association (sect.21) All inclusive	27-09-2004	A	24-08-2005	16-11-2005
Electricity Distribution Industry Holding (Pty) LTD	28-09-2004	B
Mine Health and Safety Inspectorate (no financial)	30-08-2004
Mine Health and Safety Council	31-08-2004	B
National Electricity Regulator	20-09-2004	B
(SA) Nuclear Energy Corporation Limited (NECSA)	30-08-2004
National Nuclear Regulator	07-09-2004	B
SA Diamond Board	05-10-2004	A	18-05-2005	14-09-2005	12-10-2005

NATIONAL TREASURY	28-09-2004
National Treasury - Unauthorised expenditure
Accounting Standards Board	10-09-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Corporation for Public Deposits	28-09-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Development Bank of South Africa	19-08-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Financial and fiscal Commission	02-09-2004	B		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
Financial Services Board	16-09-2004	C		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
Financial Intelligent Centre	29-09-2004	C
Government employees Pension fund	17-01-2005
Government employees Pension fund	21-06-2005
Pension Fund for Associated Institutions
Provident Fund for Associated Institutions	19-10-2004
Public Investment Commissioners	16-09-2004	B
Public Accountants' and Auditors	29-06-2005
Reconstruction and Development Programme Fund	29-10-2004
SA Reserve Bank	22-09-2004	C		22-02-2005	16-03-2005
SARS - Administered Accounts	22-09-2004
SASRIA
SASRIA	29-06-2005
Special Pensions Board	07-02-2005
Temporary Employment Pension Fund

PUBLIC ENTERPRISES	30-09-2004	B
Public Enterprises - Unauthorised expenditure
ALEXKOR	21-02-2005	B
ariva.com	26-10-2004
AVENTURA
AVENTURA	12-05-2005	B
DENEL	20-09-2004	B
ESKOM	07-06-2004	B
ESKOM	24-08-2005
SAFCOL	17-01-2005	B
TRANSNET	27-09-2004	B

PUBLIC WORKS	22-09-2004	A		09-11-2004	18-05-2005
Public Works - Unauthorised expenditure
Construction Industry Development Board	22-09-2004
Independent Development Trust	29-09-2004	C		06-04-2005	18-05-2005

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY	27-08-2004	B
Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC)	22-09-2004
The Africa Institute of South Africa (AISA)	25-08-2004	B
National Research Foundation (NRF)
The South African Agency for Science and Technology Advancement (SAASTA)
The National Laser Centre (NLC)
Ithemba Labs
The Academy of Science of SA (ASSAF)
SA Council for Natural Scientific Professions (SACNASP)
National Council on Innovation (NACI)	11-03-2005
Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR)	19-11-2004	C		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
The Council for Minerals Technology (MINTEK)	20-09-2004	B
Agricultural Research Council	01-09-2004	B
The Medical Research Council (MRC)
The Council for Geo Science	20-09-2004	C
South African Bureau of Standards (SABS)		B
The Godisa Trust
The Tshumisano Trust
The South African Environmental Observation Network (SAEON)
SA Institute for Aquatic Biodiversity (SAIAB)
SA Astribinucak Ibservatirt (SAAO)
SA Large Telescope (SALT)
The Hartebeeschoek Radio Astronomy Observatory (HartRAO)
National Zoological Gardens (NZG)
Hermanus Magnetic Observatory (HMO)

TRADE AND INDUSTRY	26-10-2004
Trade and Industry - Unauthorised expenditure
Community Public Private Partnership Programme	16-11-2004
Companies and Intellectual Property registration office (CIPRO)	22-09-2004
Competition Commission	02-09-2004	C		22-02-2005	16-03-2005
Competition Tribunal	02-09-2004	C		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
Estate Agency Affairs Board	23-08-2004
Export Credit Insurance Corporation of South Africa Limited	19-11-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Industrial Development Corporation of South Africa	14-10-2004
International Trade Administration Commission of South Africa	28-10-2004
Khula Interprise Finance		C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
Manufacturing Advisory Council
Manufacturing Development Board	14-10-2004
Micro Finance Regulatory Council	22-09-2004
National Coordination Office of the Manufacturing Advisory Centre (NAMAC)	20-10-2004	B
National Empowerment Fund	22-09-2004	B
National Gambling Board of SA	22-09-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
National Lotteries Board incl. (NLDTF)	22-09-2004	C		06-04-2005	18-05-2005
National Small Business Council	20-10-2004
SA Council for Non-Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction 2002/03	20-10-2004
SA Council for Non-Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction
Ntsika Enterprise Promotion Agency	22-09-2005	B
Proudly South African	22-09-2004
South African Excellence Foundations
South African National Accreditation System (SANAS)	30-09-2004	C		21-06-2005	14-09-2005
South African Quality Institute	20-10-2004	B
Support Programme for Industrial Innovation	19-11-2004
Trade and Investment SA	27-10-2004
Technology and Human Resources for Industry Programme (THRIP)	20-10-2004
Technology for women in Business (TWIB)	19-11-2004

TRANSPORT	19-11-2004	A
Transport - Unauthorised expenditure	30-09-2004
Air Services Licensing Council	30-09-2004
Air Traffic and Navigation Services	30-09-2004
Airports Company South Africa Limited	30-09-2004	C		14-09-2005	12-10-2005
Airports Company of South Africa Limited & Air Navigation Services Co. LTD	30-09-2005
Cross Border Road Transport Agency 03	30-09-2004
Cross Border Road Transport Agency 04	29-03-2005
Railway Safety Regulator
Roads Accident Fund	14-04-2005	A
Road Traffic Management corporation
SA Civil Aviation Authority	30-09-2004
South African Maritime Safety Authority		A
South African National Roads Agency	30-09-2004	A
South African Rail Commuter Corporation	27-01-2005
Urban Transport Fund	30-09-2004



Entities highlighted in yellow not listed but may be of interest to SCOPA?
Cat A progress/ steps scopa already dealt with and categorised
Cat B progress/ steps scopa already dealt with and categorised
Cat C progress/ steps scopa already dealt with and categorised

Group 2 Review of Annual Report Financial Statements 2003-2004

Report Name	Report Tabled	Category adopted by group	Hearing	Adopted by Plenary	Resolution for 2003/2004 tabled (ATC) in 2005
ARTS AND CULTURE	04/10/2004	B		07/09/2005
Afrikaanse Taal Museum	03/09/2004	B
ARTSCAPE	03/09/2004	B		07/09/2005
Business and Arts of South Africa	03/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	10th report tabled 02/08/2005
Engelburg House Collection	21/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	13th report tabled 02/08/2005
Freedom Park Trust	07/09/2004	B
Innovation Fund Trust
Iziko Museums of Cape Town	07/09/2004	B
Market Theatre	08/09/2004	A
Natal Museum	28/10/2004	A
National Archives Commission
National Arts Council	29/06/2005
National Film and Video Foundation	03/09/2004	C
National Library	03/09/2004	A
National Museum - Bloemfontein	31/08/2004	B		07/09/2005
Nelson Mandela Museum	21/09/2004	C
Northern Flagship Institution	03/09/2004	B
Pan South African Language Board	28/10/2004	B
Playhouse Company	21/09/2004	B
Performing Arts Centre of the Free State (PAFCOS)	31/08/2004	B
Robben Island Museum	29/06/2005
South African Blind Workers Organisation	31/08/2004	C
South African Geographical Names Council
South African Heritage Resources Agency	03/09/2004	B
South African Library for the Blind	21/09/2004	C
State Theatre	31/08/2004	A
The National English Literary Museum - Grahamstown	02/09/2004
Voortrekker and Ncome Museums	07/09/2004	A
War Museums of the Boer Republic	31/08/2004	A
William Humphreys Art Gallery	31/08/2004	C		08/06/2005	11th report tabled 02/08/2005
Windybrow Centre		A
Woordeboek van die Afrikaanse Taal
CORRECTIONAL SERVICES	30/09/2004	A	10/11/2004	15/03/2005	2nd report tabled 16/03/2005
EDUCATION	01/09/2004	A
Council on Higher Education	12/10/2004	B		07/09/2005
Education Labour Relations Council	31/08/2004	A
National Student Financial Aid Scheme	06/09/2004	B		07/09/2005
SA Certification Council
SA Council for Educators	30/08/2004	C		08/06/2005	28th report tabled 02/08/2005
SAQA	14/09/2004	B
uMalusi council for quality assurance	10/08/2004	C
South African National Accreditation System
GCIS	01/09/2004	B		07/09/2005
HEALTH	06/10/2004	A	22/02/2005	08/06/2005	23rd report tabled 02/08/2005
Compensation Commissioner for Occupational Diseases	29/04/2005	A	(31/08/2005)
Council for Medical Schemes	29/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	12th report tabled 02/08/2005
Health Donations Fund
King George V Silver Jubilee Fund
Mines and Works Compensation Fund
National Health Laboratory Service
SA National Blood Service
SA National Aids Trust
Resistrar of medical aid schemes
HOME AFFAIRS	05/10/2004	A	25/05/2005	07/09/2005
Film and Publication Board	21/10/2005
Independent Electoral Commission	25/08/2004	C		07/09/2005
HOUSING	30/09/2004	B
Lanok (casidria)
National Home Builders Registration Council (NHBRC)	29/10/2004	C		08/06/2005	24th report tabled 02/08/2005
National Housing Finance Corporation	30/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	16th report tabled 02/08/2005
National Urban Reconstruction and Housing Agency	30/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	17th report tabled 02/08/2005
People's housing partnership trust	29/10/2004	B
Rural housing loan fund	30/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	27th report tabled 02/08/2005
SA Council for Architects
SA Housing Fund	12/11/2004
Servcon Housing Solutions	30/09/2004	B
Social Housing Foundation	30/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	19th report tabled 02/08/2005
Thubelisha Home	30/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	21st report tabled 02/08/2005
JUSTICE AND CONSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT	05/10/2004
Commision on Gender Equality	05/05/2005
Commision for the Promotion and Protection of the Rights of Cultural,Religious & Linguistic Communities	29/09/2004
Guardian's Fund
South African Human Rights Commission
Independent Electoral Commission - Represented Political Parties fund	20/09/2004
Legal Aid Board	14/09/2004
National Prosecuting Authority	14/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	25th report tabled 02/08/2005
President's Fund	07/02/2005
Public Protector	31/08/2004
Special Investigating Unit	30/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	20th report tabled 02/08/2005
Truth and Reconciliation Commission
PARLIAMENT	31/08/2004 (incorrect report tabled) correct report tabled 04/11/2004	A	01/03/2005	08/06/2005	22nd report tabled 02/08/2005
PRESIDENCY	30/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	26th report tabled 02/08/2005
International Marketing Council	15/10/2004	B		07/09/2005
Media Development and Diversity Agency	02/08/2004	B		07/09/2005
National Youth Commission	10/05/2005
PROVINCIAL AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT	30/09/2004	A
Board for Municipal Accountants
Municipal Demarcation Board	29/09/2004	A	27/10/2004	08/06/2005	15th report tabled 02/08/2005
Municipal Infrastructure Investment Unit	17/09/2004	C
SA Local Government Association (SALGA)	30/09/2004	A
SA Export Statistics for Conventional Arms
National house of traditional leaders	30/09/2004
PUBLIC SERVICE AND ADMINISRATION	27/09/2004	B
State Information Technology Agency (SITA)	27/09/2004	A	08/03/2005	07/09/2005
PUBLIC SERVICE COMISSION	21/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	18th report tabled 02/08/2005
SAFETY AND SECURITY (SAPS)	20/09/2004	A	06/04/2005
Crime intellegence - Secret Services Account
Independent Complaints Directorate	21/09/2004	C		07/09/2005
SAMDI	30/09/2004	B
SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT	19/10/2004
Disaster Relief Fund
High School Vorentoe Disaster Fund
National Development Agency	14/04/2005
Refugee Relief Fund
Social Relief Fund
State President Fund
SPORT AND RECREATION SOUTH AFRICA	30/09/2004	C		08/06/2005	29th report tabled 02/08/2005
Boxing SA	10/03/2005	A
South African Institute for Drug-Free Sport	31/08/2004	C
SA Sports Commission	05/10/2004
STATISTICS SA	28/09/2004	A	16/03/2005	08/06/2005	14th report tabled 02/08/2005
WATER AFFAIRS AND FORESTRY	31/08/2004	A	22/06/2005
Albany Coast Water Board	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Amatola Water Board	17/01/2005	B
Bloem Water	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Botshelo water	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Bushbuckridge Water Board	17/01/2005	A	22/06/2005
Ikangala Water	17/01/2005	B
Lepelle Northern Water	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Magalies Water	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Mhlathuze Water	17/01/2005	C
Namaqua Water	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Overberg Water	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Pelladrift Water Board	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Rand Water	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Sedibeng Water	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Trans-Caledon Tunnel Authority	31/08/2004	C		07/09/2005
Umgeni Water	17/01/2005	C		07/09/2005
Water Research Commission	29/09/2004	C		07/09/2005

Entities highlighted in yellow not listed but may be of interest to SCOPA?
Cat A progress/ steps scopa already dealt with and categorised
Cat B progress/ steps scopa already dealt with and categorised
Cat C progress/ steps scopa already dealt with and categorised

Other committee activities (briefings on other issues, workshops, conferences)

12.1 APAC Training Kopanong Hotel and Conference Centre in Benoni, Gauteng

· Date

11^th and 12^th July 2005

· Agenda

Review of the Principles of Oversight and Accountability

Oversight in local government – new dimensions

Questioning Techniques for effective public accounts committees

The role of the Auditor-General within the framework of Public Audit Act

Method of Work of a Public Accounts Committee – Best Practices

· Presenters if any

Mr Shauket Fakie (Auditor General)

Ms Rea Borcherds

Mr Jonathan Carter (Incite)

· Resolutions

Not applicable

12.2 APAC Conference “Enhancing Oversight and Accountability in the Second Decade of our Democracy” Sun City, North West, South Africa

· Date

Sunday, 02 October 2005 to Wednesday, 05 October 2005

· Agenda

COMMISSION THEMES

Commission One: Strengthening and completing the oversight and accountability loop: Current constraints and relationships with portfolio committees

Commission Two: The relationship between the Public Accounts Committees and the Auditor-General within the framework of the Constitution and Public Audit Act

Commission Three: The effect and impact of the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA) on local government oversight

· Presenters if any

Ms L Mashiane

Mr E Trent

· Resolutions

Not applicable

Budget of the committee

· How much was allocated to the committee:

Out of an initial request for R1 827 180.00 only R558, 533.00 was approved

· Expenditure: Catering: R64 580.60

Provincial Visits: R72 526

Overseas Trips: R351 675.30

Conferences: R40 000

· Expenditure Total: R528 781.90

· Balance: R29 751.10

14. OUTSTANDING MATTERS:

15. Attach the following documents

i. Master attendance list

ii. Copies of minutes of all meetings

iii. Copies of the reports of all oversight\international visits

iv. Copy of Budget statement

SUPPORT STAFF

15.1 Control Committee Secretary:

Mr L Pakati: Facilitated plenary meetings from March 2005 – September 2005

Period from October 2002

15.2 Committee Secretaries:

Mr E R Molefe: Plenary meeting Secretary

Period from September 1999 – March 2005

Mrs N Nkabinde: Group 1 Secretary

Period from August 2001

Mr G Dixon Group 2 Secretary

Period from April 1999 (Admin. Assistant): 2003 (Committee Secretary)

15.3 Committee Assistant:

Mr M Vumazonke: Period from September 2000

(2^nd post Vacant since 2003)

15.4 Secretary to Chairperson:

Mrs X Mabindisa: Period from June 2001

15.5 Researcher (Research Unit):

Mr L Zepe: Period from March 2005

15.6 Legal Support:

Mr. D Ramurunzi: Period from June 2003

………………………………………… ………………………………………

COMMITTEE SECRETARY DATE

……………………………………………… ………………………………………

CONTROL COMMITTEE SECRETARY DATE

…………………………………… ………………………………………

COMMITTEE CHAIRPERSON: Mr N T Godi DATE

APPENDIX I

List of Entities over which the Committee Exercises Oversight

AGRICULTURE

Agricultural Research Council

Bala Farms (Pty) Ltd

Land bank

National Agricultural Marketing Council

Ncera Farms (Pty) Limited

Ondersterpoort Biological Product Limited

Perishable products export control board

ARTS AND CULTURE

Afrikaanse Taal Museum

ARTSCAPE

Business and Arts of South Africa

Freedom Park Trust

Iziko Museums of Cape Town

Market Theatre

Natal Museum

National Arts Council

National Film and Video Foundation

National Library

National Museum - Bloemfontein

National Zoological Gardens of South Africa

Nelson Mandela Museum

Northern Flagship Institution

Pan South African Language Board

Playhouse Company

Performing Arts Centre of the Free State (PAFCOS)

Robben Island Museum

South African Blind Workers Organisation

South African Heritage Resources Agency

South African Library for the Blind

State Theatre

The National English Literary Museum - Grahamstown

Voortrekker and Ncome Museums

War Museums of the Boer Republic

William Humphreys Art Gallery

Windybrow Centre

COMMUNICATION

ICASA

National Electronic Media Institute of SA

SA Post Office

SABC

SENTECH

Telkom

Universal Service Agency

Universal Service Fund

CORRECTIONAL SERVICES

DEFENCE

Armaments Corporation of South Africa (ARMSCOR)

Castle Control Board

EDUCATION

Council on Higher Education

Education Labour Relations Council

National Student Financial Aid Scheme

SA Council for Educators

SAQA

uMalusi council for quality assurance

ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS AND TOURISM

Greater St Lucia Wetland Park Authority

Marine Living Resources Fund

National Botanical Institute

South African National Parks

South African Tourism Board

South African Weather Service

FOREIGN AFFAIRS

GCIS

HEALTH

Council for Medical Schemes

National Health Laboratory Service

Medical Research Council

HOME AFFAIRS

Film and Publication Board

Independent Electoral Commission

HOUSING

National Home Builders Registration Council

National Housing Finance Corporation

National Urban Reconstruction and Housing Agency

Rural Housing fund

SA Housing fund

Servcon Housing Solutions

Social Housing Foundation

Thubelisha Home

INDEPENDENT COMPLAINTS DIRECTORATE

JUSTICE AND CONSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT

Commision on Gender Equality

Human Rights Commission

Legal Aid Board

Public Protector

Special Investigating Unit

LABOUR

Banking SETA

Chemical Industries Education and Training Authority

Clothing, textile, footwear, and leather SETA

Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration

Compensation Fund

Construction Education and Training Authority

Diplomacy, Intelligence, Defence and Trade SETA

Employment's Condition Commission

Energy SETA

ETDP, SETA

Financial and Accounting SETA

Food and Beverages SETA

Forest Industries SETA

Health and Welfare SETA

Information Systems Electronic & Telecommunications Technologies SETA

Insurance SETA

Local Government, Water and Related Services SETA

Manufacturing Engineering and Related SETA

Media, Advertising, Publishing, Printing&Packaging SETA

Mining Qualifications Authority

National Economic Development & Labour Council

National Productivity Institute

Police, Private Security, Legal and Correctional Services SETA

Primary Agricultural SETA

Secondary Agriculture SETA

Services SETA

Tourism, Hospitality and Sport SETA

Transport SETA

Umsobomvu Youth Fund

Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF)

Wholesale & Retail Services Seta

LAND AFFAIRS

Inala Farms

Ingonyama Trust Board

MINERALS AND ENERGY

Central Energy Fund incl CEF group of companies

Council for Geoscience

Electricity distribution industry holdings

Mine Health and Safety Council

MINTEK

National Electricity Regulator

(SA) Nuclear Energy Corporation Limited

National Nuclear Regulator

SA Diamond Board

NATIONAL TREASURY

Accounting Standards Board

Development Bank of South Africa

Financial and fiscal Commission

Financial intelligence centre

Financial Services Board

Public Investment Commissioners

SARS

SASRIA

PARLIAMENT

PRESIDENCY

International Marketing Council

Media Development and Diversity Agency

National Youth Commission

PROVINCIAL AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT

Commission for the Promotion of the rights of cultural, religious and linguistic communities

Municipal Demarcation Board

Municipal Infrastructure Investment Unit

SA Local Government Association (SALGA)

PUBLIC ENTERPRISES

ALEXKOR

AVENTURA

DENEL

ESCOM

SAFCOL

TRANSNET

PUBLIC SERVICE AND ADMINISRATION

SITA

PUBLIC SERVICE COMISSION

PUBLIC WORKS

Construction Industry Development Board

Independent Development Trust

SAFETY AND SECURITY

SAMDI

SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

Africa Institute of South Africa

Human Sciences Research Council

National Research Foundation

SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

National Development Agency

SPORT AND RECREATION SOUTH AFRICA

Boxing SA

South African Institute for Drug-Free Sport

SA Sports Commission

STATISTICS SA

TRADE AND INDUSTRY

Competition Commission

Competition Tribunal

Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR)

Estate Agency Affairs Board

Export Credit Insurance Corporation of South Africa Limited

Industrial Development Corporation of South Africa

International Trade Administration Commission

Khula Enterprise Finance

Manufacturing Advisory Council

National Coordination Office of the Manufacturing Advisory Centre (NAMAC)

National Empowerment Fund

National Gambling Board of SA

National Lotteries Board

Ntsika Enterprise Promotion Agency

South African Bureau of Standards (SABS)

South African Excellence Foundations

South African National Accreditation System (SANAS)

South African Quality Institute

Trade and Investment SA

TRANSPORT

Air Traffic and Navigation Services

Airports Company South Africa Limited

Cross Border Road Transport Agency

Railway Safety Regulator

Roads Accident Fund

Road Traffic Management corporation

SA Civil Aviation Authority

South African Maritime Safety Authority

South African National Roads Agency

South African Rail Commuter Corporation

Urban Transport Fund

WATER AFFAIRS AND FORESTRY

Albany Coast Water Board

Amatola Water Board

Bloem Water

Botshelo water

Bushbuckridge Water Board

Ikangala Water

Lepelle Northern Water

Magalies Water

Mhlathuze Water

Namakwa Water

Overberg Water

Pelladrift Water Board

Rand Water

Sedibeng Water

Trans-Caledon Tunnel Authority

Umgeni Water

Water Research Commission

APPENDIX II

REPORTS TABLED:

Consideration of First Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Second Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Third Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fourth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fifth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Seventh Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Eighth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Tenth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Eleventh Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Twelfth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirteenth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fourteenth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts (

Consideration of Fifteenth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixteenth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Seventeenth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Eighteenth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts.

Consideration of Nineteenth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts.

Consideration of Twentieth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Twenty-First Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Twenty-Second Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Twenty-Third Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Twenty-Fourth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Twenty-Fifth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Twenty-Sixth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Twenty-Seventh Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Twenty-Eighth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Twenty-Ninth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirtieth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirty-First Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirty-Second Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirty-Third Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirty-Fourth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirty-Fifth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirty-Sixth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirty-Seventh Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirty-Eighth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Thirty-Ninth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fortieth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Forty-First Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Forty-Second Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Forty-Third Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Forty-Fourth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Forty-Fifth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Forty-Sixth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Forty-Seventh Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Forty-Eight Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Forty-Ninth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fiftieth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fifty-First Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fifty-Second Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fifty-Third Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts (

Consideration of Fifty-Fourth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fifty-Fifth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fifty-Sixth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fifty-Seventh Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fifty-Eighth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Fifty-Ninth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixtieth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixty-First Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixty-Second Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixty-Third Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixty-Fourth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixty-Fifth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixty-Sixth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixty-Seventh Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixty-Eighth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Sixty-Ninth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Seventieth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Seventy-First Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Seventy-Second Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Seventy-Third Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Seventy-Fourth Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Consideration of Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts on a Conference hosted by ACPAC

Consideration of Report of Standing Committee on Public Accounts on a study tour of the Canadian Office of Auditor General and Standing Committee on Public Accounts

Report of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts on Study Tour to Mozambique, dated 8 November 2005

Unsigned Audit Reports

Correctional Services

APAC Conference

Competition Commission

South African Reserve Bank

Independent Development Trust

National Lotteries Board

Department of Public Works

Business and Arts South Africa

William Humphreys Art Gallery

Council for Medical Schemes

Engelenburg House Art Collection

Statistics South Africa

Municipal Demarcation Board

National Housing Finance Corporation Limited

National Urban Reconstruction and Housing Agency

Public Service Commission

Social Housing Foundation

Special Investigating Unit

Thubelisha Homes

Parliament of Republic of South Africa

National Department of Health

National Home Builders Registration Council

National Prosecuting Authority

The Presidency

Rural Housing Loan Fund

South African Council of Educators

Sport and Recreation South Africa

Unemployment Insurance Fund

Department of Defence

Land Bank and Agricultural Bank of South Africa

Accounting Standards Board

Corporation for Public Deposits

Development Bank of Southern Africa Limited

Export Credit Insurance Corporation of South Africa

Greater St Lucia Wetland Park

Khula Enterprise Finance Limited

National Botanical Institute

National Gambling Board

South African National Accreditation System

South African National Parks

Finance, Accounting, Management Consulting and Other Financial Sectors

Transport Education and Training Authority

Insurance Sector Education and Training Authority

South African Tourism

Banking Sector Education and Training Authority

Information Systems, Electronics and Telecommunications Technologies Services Sector Education and Training Authority

Forest Industries Education and Training

Health Welfare Sector Education and Training Authority

Diplomacy, Intelligence, Defence and Trade and Training Authority

Media, Advertising, Publishing, Printing and Packing Sector Education Training Authority

Tourism, Hospitality and Transport Education and Training Authority

Chemical Industries Education and Training Authority

Education, Training and Development Practises Sector Education and Training

Food and Beverage SETA

Energy Sector for Education and Training Authority

Unauthorized Expenditure (Government Communication and Information Services)

Unauthorized Expenditure (Presidency)

Unauthorized Expenditure (Department of Home Affairs)

Unauthorized Expenditure (South African Management Development Institute)

South African Diamond Board

POSLEC-SETA

Primary Agriculture Education and Training Authority (PAETA)

Financial and Fiscal Commission

Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA)

The Council for Scientific and Industrial Research

South African Broadcasting Corporation Limited (SABC)

Competition Tribunal

South African Veterinary Council

Local Government Water and Related Services Seta

Financial Services Board

Clothing, Textiles, Footwear and Leather Seta

Airports Company South Africa Ltd (ACSA)

Australasian Council of Public Accounts Committees (ACPAC) 8^th Biennial Conference, 2005

Study Tour to Canadian Office of Auditor General and Standing Committee on Public Accounts.

Study Tour to Mozambique

Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 16 March 2005, p 364 Debated – Tuesday, 7 June 2005 [Min. No 25 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 16 March 2005, p 364 - Debated – Tuesday, 7 June 2005 [Min. No 25 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 16 March 2005, p 368 - Debated – Tuesday, 7 June 2005 [Min. No 25 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 16 March 2005, p 373 - Debated – Tuesday, 7 June 2005 [Min. No 25 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 16 March 2005, p 374 - Debated – Tuesday, 7 June 2005 [Min. No 25 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 18 May 2005, p 869 - Debated – Tuesday, 7 June 2005 [Min. No 25 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 18 May 2005, p 870 - Debated – Tuesday, 7 June 2005 [Min. No 25 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 18 May 2005, p 871 - Debated – Tuesday, 7 June 2005 [Min. No 25 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1403 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1404 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1405 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1408 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1410 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1411 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1411 Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament)

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1412 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament)

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1412 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1413 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1414 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1417 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1429 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1420 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1421 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1422 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1423 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 2 August 2005, p 1426 - Debated – Tuesday, 13 September 2005 [Min. No 39 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 1990 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 1993 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 1994 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 1995 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 1996 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 1997 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 1998 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 1999 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 2000 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 2001 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 2001. - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 2002 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 2003 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 2004 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 2005 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 2006 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 14 September 2005, p 2007 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2268- Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2269 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2270 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2271 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2272- Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2273 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2274 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2275 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2276 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2277 -) Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament.

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2278 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2279 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2280 - Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2280 -. Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 12 October 2005, p 2281 – Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliament).

(Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports, 3 August 2005, p 1490 Debated – Tuesday, 08 November 2005 [Min. No 49 - 2005] Second Session, Third Parliamen)

Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports 14 November 2005 No 147 - 2005 Second Session, Third Parliament

Report to be considered.”