AIM OF PRESENTATION: THE AIM OF THIS PRESENTATION IS TO PROVIDE AN OVERVIEW OF THE PUBLIC HEARINGS INTO THE DEFENCE REVIEW AS CONDUCTED BY THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE OF DEFENCE WITH SPECIFIC REGARD TO THE FOLLOWING:


A. THE SUBMISSIONS MADE TO THE COMMITTEE

B. THE PRESENTATIONS MADE TO THE COMMITTEE

C. THE RECCOMENDATIONS EMERGING FROM THE SUBMISSIONS

D. COMMON THEMES EMERGING FROM THE SUBMISSIONS.


RECOMMENDATIONS EMERGING FROM THE SUBMISSIONS TO THE COMMITTEE FORCE STRUCTURE AND FORCE LEVEL CONSIDERATIONS


1. THE NEED TO DETERMINE THE AN APPROPRIATE SIZE AND COMPOSITION OF THE FORCE IN TERMS OF AGE PROFILE, SKILLS RETENTION AND OPERATIONAL CAPABILITIES


2. THE IMPACT OF AIDS ON THE COMBAT READINESS OF THE SANDF - NEED FOR A SCIENTIFIC ASSESSMENT.


3. NEED TO EXAMINE POSSIBLE ARENAS WHERE EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT AND SAVINGS CAN BE EFFECTED WITHIN THE DOD.


4. NEED FOR AN ACCURATE ASSESSMENT OF REQUIRED FORCE LEVELS FOR BOTH THE REGULAR FORCE AND THE RESERVE FORCE.

HUMAN RESOURCE CONSIDERATIONS


5. THE NEED FOR A COMPREHENSIVE CIVIC EDUCATION CAMPAIGN WITHIN THE DOD THAT RECTIFIES THE PERCEIVED FALTERING PACE OF THE CURRENT PROGRAMME.


6. THE NEED TO RESTRUCTURE THE SERVICE CORPS AS PART OF AN OVERALL DEMOBILIZATION STRATEGY.


7. NEED FOR AN ADEQUATE, INTEGRATED AND WELL- RESOURCED VETERANS AFFAIRS DIRECTORATE.


8. NEED TO REVITALIZE THE RESERVES IN TERMS OF THEIR BUDGETARY. HUMAN RESOURCE AND DEPLOYMENT REQUIREMENTS


9. NEED FOR AN INDEPENDENT GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE WITHIN THE DOD FOR DOD PERSONNEL


ROLES AND FUNCTIONS


10. NEED TO REVISIT THE PRIMARY AFFORDED THE "PRIMARY FUNCTION" WITH REGARD TO POLICY, PLANNING, PROGRAMMING, FORCE EMPLOYMENT AND BUDGETARY CONSIDERATIONS.

  1. THE NEED TO PRIORITIZE PEACE MISSIONS IN GENERAL


12. THE NEED TO INTEGRATE PEACE MISSIONS WITHIN A BROADER HUMAN SECURITY AND CIVILIAN ORBIT


13. NEED TO PROVIDE MISSION SPECIFIC EQUIPMENT AND PERSONNEL FOR PEACE MISSIONS PARTICIPATION.

STRATEGIC CONSIDERATIONS


14. THE NEED TO INTEGRATE AND BALANCE HUMAN SECURITY WITH MILITARY SECURITY NEEDS


15. NEED FOR A NATIONAL PEACE AND STABILITY STRATEGY THAT INTEGRATES "TRADITIONAL" SECURITY AND HUMAN SECURITY NEEDS.


16. NEED TO MOVE TOWARDS A DEFENSIVE POSTURE THAT PRIORITIZES CONFIDENCE BUILDING WITHIN THE SUB- REGION ("CONFIDENCE-BUILDING DEFENCE")


17. NEED TO EXPAND EARLY WARNING AND INTELLIGENCE CAPABILITY ON BOTH A NATIONAL AND CONTINENTAL LEVE


18. REQUIREMENT TO ADVANCE REGIONAL AND CONTINENTAL SECURITY REGIMES AND ARRANGEMENTS (AU, SADC, OPDS, NEPAD ETC).


19. NEED TO OPERATIONALIZE THE SADC MUTUAL DEFENCE PACT.


20. NEED TO DEEPEN THE AFRICAN UNION'S SECURITY CAPABILITIES.


21. NEED TO FORMULATE A COMPREHENSIVE "THREAT ANALYSIS" (STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT).


22. NEED FOR A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF THE READINESS LEVELS OF THE AFRICAN STANDBY FORCE.


DEFENCE INDUSTRY AND TECHNOLOGICAL CONSIDERATIONS


23. NEED TO EXAMINE THE CONTROL REGIME THAT GOVERNS THE TRANSFER OF TECHNOLOGY AND DEFENCE MATERIAL


24. POSSIBLE INTRODUCTION OF A LICENSING VERSUS A PERMIT SYSTEM TO REDUCE ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN ON ARMS TRANSFERS


25. MERGING RXISTING ARMS EXPORT LEGISLATION AND AUTHORITIES TO REDUCE DELAYS IN THE SYSTEM (SEE WHITE PAPER ON DEFENCE RELATED INDUSTRIES)


26. POSSIBLE INCLUSION OF AN ADDITIONAL CHAPTER IN THE DEFENCE REVIEW ON DEFENCE TECHNOLOGICAL REQUIREMENTS.


27. CONSOLIDATION OF STATE OWNED DEFENCE, SCIENCE, ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGICAL CAPABILITIES UNDER A SINGLE AUTHORITY


28. ESTABLISHMENT OF A DEFENCE SET RESPONSIBLE FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF DEFENCE, ENGINEERING AND TECHNLOGICAL CAPABILITIES


29. EXPANSION OF THE SET CAPABILITIES BASE THROUGH APPROPRIATE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE ALLOCATION.


30. THE NEED TO AUDIT LAND CLAIMS AGAINST SANDG PROPERTIES AND ASSESS WHETHER LAND DISPOSAL CANNOT MORE EFFECTIVELY BENEFIT DEVELOPMENTAL NEEDS


OTHER

31. THE NEED TO EXAMINE THE "OFF-SET" AND COUNTER- TRADE ASSUMPTIONS UPON WHICH MUCH OF THE ARMS DEAL WAS "SOLD" TO THE PUBLIC


COMMON THEMES AND ISSUES

1. REQUIREMENT TO REVISIT THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN THE PRIMARY AND THE SECONDARY FUNCTIONS


2. IMPORTANCE OF PLACING A GREATER EMPHASIS ON THE ROLE OF PEACE MISSIONS WITHIN GOVERNMENT POLICY IN GENERAL AND DEFENCE POLICY IN PARTICULAR.


3. THE IMPORTANCE OF INTRODUCING THE HUMAN SECURITY DIMENSION MORE PRO-ACTIVELYAND MORE POLICY-EFFECITVELY INTO THE DEFENCE POLICY PARADIGM


4. THE IMPORTANCE OF RETAINING AND DEVELOPING DEFENCE TECHNOLOGICAL CAPABILITIES.


5. THE IMPORTANCE OF DEMOBILIZATION AND RIGHT- SIZING WITHIN THE CURRENT DEFENCE COMMUNITY


6. CONSIDERING DEFENCE CONVERSION ISSUES IN MORE DETAIL - PARTICULARLY BASE CLOSURE AND LAND RESTITUTION


A GENERAL APPRECIATION FOR THE CONSULTATIVE NATURE OF THE REVIEW OF THE REVIEW AND THE INVOLVEMENT OF CIVIL SOCIETY THEREIN!

 

DEFENCE REVIEW-SUBMISSIONS RECEIVED

Date Received

Name

Organisation

Official/Private Capacity

Verbal submission ( /x

1

20\09\04

K Neethling

Herald(Swartland & Weskus)

 

 

2

20\09\04

Motshumi

Conservation-with God

 

 

3

29\09\04

Terry Crawford-Brown

ECAAR-SA

 

 

4

30\0904

TM Jorgensen

Danish Institute for International Studies

 

 

5

30\09\04

J Sekete

 

 

 

6

01\10\04

Martin Cuff

Cape Films- Commission

 

 

7

01\10\04

Lt Col JU vd Westhuijzen

Chairman: Reserve Force Council (Western Cape)

 

 

8

01\10\04

DS Mathe

Advisory Board on Military Veterans Affair

 

 

9

04\10\04

Mohapi OB

 

 

 

10

04\10\04

C Van Niekerk

SANDU

 

 

11

18\10\04

Ms L Ntloko

SASFU

 

 

12

04\10\04

Mr GT Geduldt

Private

 

 

14

08\10\04

Mr L Le Roux

Institute for Security Studies

 

 

15

08\10\04

Adv M Pothier

Catholic Bishop’s Conference

 

 

16

08\10\04

Chemist Khumalo

Ceasefire Campaign

 

 

17

12\10\04

Mr G Lamb

Centre for Conflict Resolution

 

 

18

15\10\04

Mr Wesley

CSIR

 

 

19

26\10\04

Ms J February

IDASA

 

 

20

12\10\04

Che Ajulu

Garth Sheldon

Institute for Global Dialogue

 

 

21

13\10\04

Dr N Mlambo

Africa Institute of South Africa

 

 

22

19\10\04

PWE Labuschagne

AMD

 

 

23

20\10\04

F Krill

International Committee of the Red Cross

 

 

24

22\10\04

Maj G Maphalala

Army Support Base Dequar Rd

 

 

25

22\10\04

ICRC

International Comm of the Red Cross

 

 

26

28\10\04

Geoff Harris

United Kingdom