The Speaker
Letter from the Minister of Finance dated 16 November 2004 to the
Speaker of the National Assembly, in terms of section 8(3) of the
Public Finance Management Act, 1999 (Act No 1 of 1999), explaining
the delay in the tabling of the consolidated financial statements for
2003-2004:
Dear Madam Speaker
Reasons for the delay in submitting the consolidated statements in
terms of section 8(3) of the PFMA
I am writing to advise that the tabling of the consolidated financial
statements in terms of section 8(3) of the PFMA will be delayed and
to request an extension for the tabling thereof in Parliament as
required by the Act.
Section 8(3) of the PFMA stipulates ‘‘The Minister must submit the
consolidated financial statements and the audit report on those
statements within one month of receiving the report from the
Auditor-General, to Parliament for tabling in both houses’’. The
timing referred to in this instance is by the end of October 2004.
Section 8(5)(a) requires me to provide a written explanation setting
out the reasons for failing to submit the statements on time.
The cause for the delay is due to the following:
* The financial year that ended on 31 March 2004 is the first for
which such consolidated financial statements are required.
Departments and entities have thus been exposed to the
complexities of these requirements for the first time. The formats
for the consolidation thus pose a challenge to all the stakeholders;
* The sequence of submitting the financial statements in terms of
section 40 of the PFMA results in certain difficulties in meeting
timelines;
* The consolidations done on the previous years’ information
raised serious issues with regard to the integrity of the
information, hence the need for a more thorough approach
during the first year of consolidation;
* The systems are not functioning optimally and are not readily
aligned to cater for the new requirements. As a result, the
consolidation is essentially done manually with the use of
spreadsheets;
* Most public entities did not comply with the deadline for
submitting the statements; and
* The audits for most of the departments were only finalised
during September 2004. This was largely due to problems
experienced with the quality of the information submitted to the
Auditor-General.
The National Treasury expects to table the consolidated financial
statements in terms of section 8(3) of the PFMA by February 2005. I
have instructed the National Treasury to put mechanisms in place to
prevent the recurrence of these problems in future.
The National Treasury and the Auditor-General have discussed the
possibility of delaying the consolidated financial statements. Both
parties have agreed that it would be sensible to delay publishing and
first allow for the issues to be addressed comprehensively in order to
ensure a firm foundation for the future.
Kind regards,
signed
TREVOR A MANUEL, MP
MINISTER OF FINANCE