Report of the Portfolio Committee on Communications on Budget Vote 27 – Communications, dated 24 August 2004:
The Committee on Communications has examined the budget of the Department
of Communications (Vote 27) for the 2004/05 financial year and the estimates for
2005/06 and 2006/07 included in the Estimates of National Expenditure 2004,
and reports as follows:
A. The DoC (Department of Communications)
The DoC’s vision, mission and key performance areas (KPAs)
The vision of the department is to be a global leader in harnessing information
and communications technologies for socioeconomic development while its
mission is to enhance the wellbeing of peoples of South Africa, the African
Continent and the world through the creation of a sustainable and an enabling
information communications technology (ICT) environment. As part of its mission,
it endeavours to, through leveraging its world-class knowledge, skills and
experience, deliver on its social contracts to the people in a professional manner
reflective of its national value system and informed by Batho Pele ethos.
The DoC’s vision and mission are underpinned by the following key performance
areas:
__ A policy framework to facilitate universal access.
__ Develop an e-strategy framework.
__ Develop an ICT framework.
__ Develop and ICT competition framework.
__ Develop mechanisms to support local content.
__ Finalise the Convergence Bill.
__ Produce a migration policy framework for public broadcasting.
__ Facilitate the restructuring of SOEs (state-owned enterprises).
__ Oversee the delivery of Government-policy targets.
___ Facilitate the appointment of boards of directors of SOEs.
___ Analyse SOEs’ financial performance.
___ Undertake a benchmarking exercise on the financial performance of SOEs.
___ Evaluate the financial implications of universal obligations.
___ Analyse convergent technologies.
___ Analyse the viability of emergent technologies to enable universal access.
___ Develop a network model for the provision of educational services.
___ Provide affordable and high-quality access of regional broadcasting.
___ Ensure compatibility and interoperability of ICT standards.
___ Facilitate the development of strategic planning.
___ Ensure effective participation in intergovernmental activities.
___ Promote equity of designated groups in DoC.
___ Build mutually beneficial relations in the ICT sector.
___ Develop an effective SADC ICT substructure with a clear ICT programme.
___ Promote South African business on the Continent and internationally.
___ To assist the Minister in ensuring and maintaining effective, efficient and
transparent systems of financial and risk management, internal controls, and
a fair procurement and provision system.
___ Budget management and financial control.
___ Provide a secretary service to the DTC.
___ To ensure and maintain effective and appropriate steps to prevent
unauthorised, irregular, fruitless and wasteful expenditures and losses.
Table 1: The DoC’s Medium-term Expenditure F ramework Estimates
Programme Adjusted
Appropriation
2003/04
Revised
estimate
2003/04
2004/05 MTEF
2005/06
2006/07
Administration 88 607 84 198 91 269 95 292 101 008
Telecommunications
Policy
146 796 144 062 134 649 142 670 151 230
Postal Services 1 090 186 1 088 027 356 490 372 199 394 531
Multi-media
Services
312 948 312 319 285 668 296 904 316 298
Auxiliary and
Associated Services
6 682 6 356 7 124 7 438 7 884
Total 1 645 219 1 634 962 875 200 914 503 970 951
S AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
Table 2: MTEF per Econom ic Classification
Economic
Classification
Adjusted
Appropriation
2003/04
Revised
estimate
2003/04
2004/05 MTEF
2005/06
2006/07
Current
payments
225 413 215 156 202 463 224 497 242 169
Transfers and
subsidies
1 403 702 1 403 701 647 224 662 384 699 007
Payments for
capital assets
16 105 16 105 25 513 27 622 29 775
Total 1 645 219 1 634 962 875 200 914 503 970 951
Note: R750 million was allocated under transfers to the Post Bank for the 2003/04 financial
year. The 112 Emergency Call Centre has been allocated R20 million under capital assets
whereas it was part of the transfers in the previous financial year.
Table 3: T ransfer Payment Details
Transfer to
Adjusted
Appropriation
2003/04
2004/05 MTEF
2005/06
2006/07
USA 14 211 15 884 17 500 20 100
USF 24 745 26 230 29 400 31 164
Advanced
Institute for ICT
11 000 13 000 7 000 -
ISETT-seta - 2 350 2 800 3 300
Multi-purpose
Community
Centres
- 2 000 3 000 3 500
South African
Post Office
subsidy
1 050 000 300 000 300 000 318 000
SAPO: Pit - 8 480 10 000 10 800
SAPO: Extension
of Services
- 7 950 8 500 9 000
SABC: public
broadcaster
44 717 47 400 50 455 53 482
SABC: TBVC
states
40 000 - - -
SABC: Channel
Africa
26 288 27 865 29 616 31 393
Community
Radio Stations
9 000 9 540 10 255 10 870
Programme
Production
30 100 28 500 31 000 33 200
NEMISA 15 153 16 878 18 163 19 199
A Summary of the DoC’s Budget
The 2004 Estimates of National Expenditure reports an uneven spending during
the past three financial years by the DoC, mainly as a result of the spending on
the Post Office subsidy. This subsidy was removed in 2000/01, but was
reintroduced in the 2001/02 and 2002/03 financial years.
The DoC budget appears to be in line with the Government’s expenditure
priorities. It should be interpreted against the backdrop of the extension of key
public services, particularly in the social sector and in infrastructure delivery. The
budget prioritises services that target the poor and vulnerable groups, while
advancing programmes that provide greater impetus for economic growth and
broad-based development.1
In 2002/03, the department’s revenue was R50,3 million, made up as follows:
__
Interest from the SABC: R1,8 million.__
Licence fee paid by the Post Office: R25,4 million.__
Recoveries of previous financial years’ expenditure: R0,6 million.__
Short-term interest received from the current bank account: R22,5 million.In the current financial year, the department received R53,0 million, made up as
follows:
__
Interest received: R25,7 million.__
Licence fee paid by the Post Office: R26,9 million.DoC: Points raised by members of the committee
1. A Coherent Framework: The DoC must provide communications access
within a coherent framework, involving all sectors of society.
2. Frequency Sharing: National requirements on frequency sharing are to be
submitted by October 2004, followed by timeframes on migration.
3. ICT Application: ICTs are to be applied in the delivery of social services, viz.
in education, health, agricultural production, crime prevention, etc.
4. An Intersectoral Approach: An intersectoral approach is favoured to
migration initiatives since the DoC cannot be the only role-player in such
initiatives.
5. Migration of Broadcasting: Broadcasting must be migrated into the new
broadcasting arena, continentally and internationally.
6. Outreach across Government Departments: Various Government
Departments, such as Home Affairs, Minerals and Energy, Science and
Technology, and Trade and Industry, apply ICTs – the DoC, therefore, could
play an interactive role in such initiatives.
7. A Policy Framework: A policy framework for the public broadcaster is
currently required.
8. Public-private Partnerships: The private sector’s research capacity could be
harnessed and could involve the DoC as a strategic partner.
1 As quoted from the 2004 Budget Review, p. 120.
544 [Tuesday, 24 August 2004
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
9. Research: Rapid progress in technology application necessitates applied
research in the fields of IT and ICT applications, with a strong focus on
convergence technologies.
10. Restrictions: Unnecessary restrictions on communications technology may
have to be removed.
11. Restructuring: The DoC envisages the restructuring of its economic cluster,
initiated by its parastatals. These will be implemented up to Cabinet level.
12. SMMEs should assist in lowering the cost of communications.
13. Universal Access: Since not all South Africans receive broadcasting, the
DoC must develop a policy framework for universal access.
B. Nemisa (National E lectronic Media Institute of South Africa)
Established in 1998 and funded through the DoC, Nemisa’s mandate is to
provide a bridge between academic training and work or employment, focusing
on traditional broadcasting such as radio and television production training.
Nemisa’s board of directors is appointed by the Minister of Communications, with
a staff complement of 26 (including management). Attracting students from all
over South Africa, Nemisa’s main focus is on administration.
It currently offers the following 3 tertiary qualifications: (a) the Radio Production
Diploma, which places the focus on introduction to radio, current affairs
programming for radio, research and programme development, post production
and packaging, writing for radio and a three-month internship; (b) the Television
Production Diploma focuses on writing for television, news gathering, processing
and presentation, camera and lighting, production and post productions, audio
and graphics, and a three-month internship, and (c) Creative Multimedia
(animation design and information design).
Table 1: Nemisa’s S tudent Statistics
2000 2001 2002 2004
Programme Enrolled Completed Enrolled Completed Enrolled Completed Enrolled Completed
Creative
Multimedia
- -
40 27 25
21 will
complete
June 2004
38 ?
Television
Production 17 17 22 20 - - 21 ?
Radio
Production 14 14 18 15 - - 15 ?
Tuesday, 24 August 2004] 545
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
Table 2: Nemisa’s M edium-term expenditure a llocation
2003/04 R15 153 000
2004/05 R16 878 000
2005/06 R18 163 000
2006/07 R19 199 000
Table 3: Nemisa’s S ources o f Funding
Percentage Source of Funding
84% Grants
8% Administrative Fees
6% Equipment/Facility Hire
2% Short Courses
Table 4: Nemisa’s 2003/04 expenditure
Percentage Expenditure Item
34% Staff-related Expenses
26% Operational Expenses
21% Lease rental
13% Student Costs
6% Licence Fees
A Summary of Nemisa’s Budget in terms of the Budget allocation to DoC
Nemisa’s budget forms part of Programme 4, the Multi-media Service Policy, of
the DoC budget, which is made up of the Policy and Legal cluster, the Finance,
Budgeting and Shareholder cluster, the Community Services cluster, and the
New Services cluster. The budget allocated to these four clusters addresses the
formulation of policy and regulations with regard to convergence from an
analogue to a digital system, restructuring of the SABC, South African content
and local production, with a focus on funding for local content development, for
infrastructure roll-out, funding of the digitisation of infrastructure, and funding for
broadcasting services in South Africa’s 11 languages.
Nemisa’s sources of revenue for the 2004/05 financial year is as follows:
Grants R16,878 million.
Learnerships R500 000.
Other R2,6 million
546 [Tuesday, 24 August 2004
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
Nemisa: Points raised by members of the committee
__ Channel Africa: At present, Channel Africa receives all its funds from the
State. If Channel Africa’s position is to be sustained and strengthened, other
sources of funding should be explored.
__ Communications: Indications are that the creation of competition (for
instance a third cellular operator) either had a marginal impact on price
reduction, or no impact at all. Although competition in the communications
sector does not appear to have an immediate impact on the lowering of
prices, over a period of four to five years, the price of some communications
facilities may come down.
__ Convergence: The Convergence Bill will be tabled in national Parliament in
the third quarter of this year. Technology-specific legislation which could
hamper convergence may have to be removed. Drawn-out licencing
processes drain Nemisa’s resources.
__ Economy: In the process of managing progress in the ICT and the
communications sector (with particular reference to a Second National
Operator) cognisance must be taken of South Africa’s dual economy. The
State must play a role in serving all of its citizens; it must create
employment, bring down the price of communications, provide universal
access and close the digital divide which separate the haves from the havenots.
__ Multi-purpose Community Centres (MPCCs) are vitally important links to
communications technology, particularly in rural areas. Funding to MPCCs
poses an ongoing challenge.
__ Skills Shortage: Nemisa’s role in identifying skills shortages in key areas
such as research, development and training has to be done in partnership
with, amongst others, the Department of Education; the institute is not in a
position to address these shortages alone.
__ Students: Nemisa currently places approximately 60% of its students in the
media industry. Addressing the skills shortage in the media sector is of
paramount importance, with particular reference to progress to the level of
full employment of Nemisa’s students.
C. SAPO (South A frican P ost O ffice)
A synopsis of the Post Office’s operational environment:
SAPO’s mission includes connectivity through the distribution of information,
goods and financial services. Its short-term objectives are to:
__ Curb postal crime.
__ Improve its delivery performance.
__ Reach a financial break-even point in the near future.
Tuesday, 24 August 2004] 547
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
SAPO’s reported key achievements
__ As of 31 March, its operating loss was reversed to an operating profit of
R35,5 million (with an initial target of R1,8 million).
__ An improvement of R205 million in operating profit.
__ A 6,3% revenue growth (R261 million).
__ A 1% cost increase.
__ An aggressive approach to managing costs and curtailing non-value adding
expenditure.
__ The creative management of capital expenditure through partnerships.
__ A decrease in staff numbers of 1 042 due to voluntary packages.
__ An improvement of working capital.
__ A reduction of Post Office debtor days from 30 to 20.
___ Generating approximately R270 million cash from operations.
___ A year to March 2004 growth of R560 million in Postbank’s depositor’s book.
___ The introduction of the Thuso insurance product and new savings products.
___ A growth of 28% in new accounts (528 000).
SAPO’s balance sheet improvements
__ Negative retained earnings of R1,4 billion as at March 2004.
__ The aforementioned is to be resolved by means of:
a. A reduction in post-retirement medical aid liability of R2,3 billion
(provided R1,1 billion).
b. The Postbank recapitalisation of R750 million.
c. A review of property values.
d. Sustainable profitable performance.
SAPO reported the following 2003/04 key projects
__ 51 Post Offices have been installed with "new image" or upgraded.
__ SAP upgrade.
__ E-BDN.
__ Fixed-assets project.
__ Server consolidation.
__ Upgrade of the network.
__ Biometrics.
__ On-line private box renewals.
__ Financial switch.
SAPO’s pensioner position
SAPO reported that pensioners who retired prior to 1994 enjoy lucrative PRMA
benefits, some contribute less than a third, whilst other make no contribution, and
a part of the benefits was provided by the previous Government, which resulted
in a huge liability for SAPO. An agreement was signed in 1994 for pensioners
548 [Tuesday, 24 August 2004
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
who retired after this date – prior to the election of the democratic Government.
Approximately 1 500 pensioners are previous Government pensioners – those
who form part of this major liability.
SAPO’s financial liability
Currently, SAPO’s liability stands at approximately R2,3 billion, impacting
negatively on the net effect of the balance sheet, which escalates annually.
Current SAPO employees are obliged to contribute a third towards medical aid.
SAPO reported the following initiatives to reduce liability
__ The removal of this benefit for all newly-appointed or promoted employees
since October 2002.
__ Capping the benefit for all employees on total package dispensation.
__ SAPO brought off the benefit for employees who opted for voluntary
packages thus far.
SAPO reported the following contribution reserve
__ SAPO invested approximately R138 million for reserve funding, which has
grown to approximately R340 million.
__ As a commercial settlement, the board of trustees proposed to allocate
R250 million to the company, and the balance of R90 million to the fund.
__ For technical reasons, the aforementioned has not been implemented.
SAPO’s 2003/04 Financial overview
Operating income R4 352 474 000
Operating expenses R4 316 946 000
Operating profit R35 528 000
SAPO: Points raised by members of the committee
__ Public Information Terminals (PITs): Although PIT activities are important to
SAPO in providing information and Internet training, SAPO could not
determine the trend of usage.
__ Delivery: SAPO’s current delivery of 6,5 million letters a day should not be
seen as a limit; SAPO hopes that the volume of letters for delivery will grow.
__ Mail delivery in informal settlements: Some SAPO staff is currently trained
for mail delivery in such areas. The commercial banks share SAPO’s
concern that mail should be delivered to such areas, bearing in mind that the
majority of such areas do not have water and sanitation. SAPO works
together with the National Address Database, the metro cities, and the
provincial and local governments in order to deliver mail in informal
settlements.
__ SAPO’s pension liability relates to the life expectancy of its pensioners.
According to research done by SAPO, its pensioners generally have a life
expectancy of 20 years following their retirement, together with continued
membership of dependents.
__ Staff reduction: Since staff and transport costs present SAPO’s major items
of expenditure, it had to find acceptable ways to reduce its staff numbers. In
doing so, SAPO sticks to voluntary retrenchment.
__ Stamps: SAPO expressed the wish that South African stamps produced will
motivate people to collect stamps. Indications are that the philately industry
is growing rapidly. This view is supported by the 1998 White Paper on
Postal Policy, which encouraged SAPO to develop a strategy to expand the
collector’s market and to develop and improve philately services.2
__ Universal access is equally important to SAPO as to the other
communications role-players. The delivery of mail in some areas and the
non-delivery in other areas is changed to a non-discriminatory approach. For
that reason, the building of infrastructure in rural areas is equally important
to the maintenance of well-equipped centres in affluent urban areas.
D. ICASA (Independent Communications
Authority o f South Africa)
Established in July 2000, in terms of the ICASA Act, Act 13 of 2000, ICASA
regulates the telecommunications and the broadcasting sectors. The authority
derives its mandate from the Independent Broadcasting Act of 1993, the
Broadcasting Act of 1999 and the Telecommunications Authority Act of 1996.
Law
__ Since ICASA operates in a highly litigious environment, it constantly deals
with litigation.
__ In the 2003/04 financial year, ICASA faced 10 litigation matters, the majority
of which are instituted in the High Court and the Supreme Court of Appeal,
which required external legal counsel.
__ Its legal department had a R3 000 000 budget in 2003/04 for external legal
fees.
__ The lack of budget results in decisions having to be made not to oppose
matters in court and to abide by court decisions.
__ Increased funding would enable ICASA’s legal department to defend its
decisions more effectively.
2 Source: The White Paper on Postal Policy, 1998, published by the Department of
Communications.
Communications
__ Media liaison.
__ Stakeholder liaison (a stakeholders meeting is held annually).
__ The communications department exhibited at several exhibition sites in the
2003/04 financial year at a cost of R245 000.
__ Newspaper subscriptions at a cost of R117 000 are managed for council
and staff by ICASA’s communications unit.
__ Staff functions are co-ordinated to commemorate events.
Consumer protection
__ The communications unit intensified its outreach programmes.
__ It held road shows in the Eastern Cape, Northern Cape and Mpumalanga
provinces.
__ Addresses are given at schools, public functions, clinics and municipal
events, and radio programmes are conducted for public education.
__ Promotional material is procured for these events.
__ Educational officers conducted public awareness programmes.
__ A pamphlet – a guide to telecommunications – has been produced and
distributed.
__ A memorandum of understanding was signed with telecommunications
operators on dealing with consumer complaints.
__ A committee for the disabled to liaise with organisations representing the
disabled in order to keep abreast of the needs and problems encountered by
the disabled.
__ Similar committees and consumer groups would be established given
increased funding.
Council support
__ The council support unit supported ICASA processes.
__ 18 hearings were held in 2003/04 co-ordinated by the unit.
__ Books, publications and membership to professional organisations for
councilors are procured by this unit.
__ Increased funding would facilitate more intensive workshops for councilors
to keep them updated with legal and technological developments.
International relations
__ ICASA supports and subscribes to TRASA (the Telecommunications
Regulators of South Africa), the International Telecommunications Union
(ITU), the AUT, RIARC (Reseau de Partenaires des Medias Africains),
SABA (the South African Broadcasting Association) and participates in
international ministerial meetings.
__ It hosts TRASA workshops and contributes to TRASA activities.
__ ICASA was appointed to chair RIARC at the last AGM.
__ Further involvement in international events would enable ICASA to conduct
studies and attend training to strengthen its regulatory capabilities in line
with international standards.
__ Translations and interpretation costs are incurred with hosting delegations
and translation of documents, and ICASA hosts visits from other African
states.
ICASA’s key 2004/05 outcomes are to –
__ Minimise litigation risks.
__ Procure a complaints management system.
__ Continue outreach and road shows.
__ Increased funding would enable ICASA to reach many more areas.
__ Enforce MoU on complaints handling.
__ More stakeholder meetings.
__ Implement local media monitoring.
__ Investigate the establishment of a call centre.
ICASA’s telecommunications policy analysis
__ Finalised regulations i.r.o. COA/CAM for mobile operators and regulations
i.r.o. PSTN-to-PSTN interconnection.
__ Reviewed carrier pre-selection regulations.
__ Developed guidelines for trial and launch of new services and the legality of
wireless local area networks (WLANs).
__ Commenced with the development of number portability regulations which
will satisfy the needs of South African users.
ICASA’s Telecommunicatons outputs for 2004/05 include:
__ A central-numbering database.
__ Number-portability regulations.
__ Reviewing the fixed-line tariff regime.
__ Telkom’s PSTS licence.
__ The short-code strategy.
__ The SNO licence.
__ Under-serviced area licencing.
Telecommunications: licencing, enforcement and number administration, a
synopsis
__ Carried out most of the processes towards the licencing of under-serviced
area licences.
__ Developed a comprehensive framework for the licencing and regulation of
VANs and PTNs.
552 [Tuesday, 24 August 2004
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
__ Developed a numbering plan that will encourage competition within the
sector.
__ Began development of a short-code strategy for South Africa.
__ Started work on the amendment of Telkom’s licence in preparation for
competition.
__ Updating and finalising terms and conditions for the SNO licence whilst
amending the Telkom licence.
__ Developing a central numbering database as required in terms of the Act.
__ Undertook the licence amendment process for Sentech and for WBS.
__ Continuously clamping down on illegal providers of telecommunication
services.
Key objectives and expected telecommunications outputs for 2004/05
__ Second phase of under-serviced area licencing.
__ Finalisation and issuing of the SNO licence and Telkom’s PSTS licence.
__ Development and subsequent management of the central numbering
database.
__ Finalisation of the short-code strategy.
__ Development of functional specification and order handling, Mobile
Operators QoS Audit Performance Indicator regulations, and of
Telkom/SNO service target audit performance indicator regulations.
__ Finalisation of number portability regulations.
__ Review of fix-line tariff regime.
__ Implement COA/CAM for mobile operators and for PSTS.
__ Undertake a formal market determination in the sector.
Telecommunications DFID assistance
Project Estimate
PSTN-to-PSTN interconnection R800 000-00
Review of Carrier Preselection regulations R275 000-00
Under-serviced area licencing process R495 000-00
Number portability R515 000-00
Numbering plan R255 000-00
Numbering database R616 000-00
Mobile COA/CAM R230 000-00
Total R3 186 000-00
ICASA’s broadcasting objectives, a synopsis:
__ Review: Ownership and control broadcasting services and existing
commercial sound broadcasting licences.
__ Position paper on local television leading to the licencing of SABC 4 and 5.
__ Discussion paper: Subscription broadcasting leading to possible licencing of
satellite subscription broadcasting services.
__ Amendment: South African Content Regulation.
__ Position paper completed under year of review:
a. Sports Broadcasting Rights.
b. Low-power Broadcasting.
c. Published Code of Conduct for Broadcasters and technical
amendments to the ICASA South African Television Content
Regulation of 2002.
Future Broadcasting Policy Project 2004/05
__ Policy projects:
a. Review of community radio policy and of signal distribution.
b. Ten-year review of broadcasting regulation in South Africa.
c. Review of advertising and sponsorship rules.
d. Programming requirements for the disabled and the elderly.
__ Election monitoring: ICASA monitored 44 502 items during the election
period and reported a total data capture error ratio of 0,15%.
Broadcasting: licencing
__ SABC licence renewal - ICASA renewed 18 sound broadcasting services
and 3 television broadcasting services.
__ Commercial sound broadcasting service renewals – ICASA renewed the
following six commercial radio services: YFM, Jacaranda FM, Kaya FM, P4
Cape Town and Classic FM.
__ Radio Oranje was granted amendments to its application.
__ ICASA approved the Nail transaction and completed the four-year
community broadcasting licence process to all 9 provinces in South Africa.
Broadcasting: Future Licencing Project 2004/05
__ Licencing of subscription broadcasting services.
__ Licencing of community services.
__ Licencing of low-power broadcasting.
__ Renewal of Orbicom Category 2 Signal Distribution.
Broadcasting: the positive impact of adequate funding
__ Adequate funding will ensure quick responses to new technological
advances.
__ Timeous delivery.
__ Ensure the retention of good personnel.
__ Hire the best consultants.
554 [Tuesday, 24 August 2004
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
Engineering and technology: frequency spectrum
__ Publication of an annual terrestrial broadcasting frequency plan.
__ Issue frequency spectrum licences to radio communications operators:
(4 800 new and 89 000 in total)
__ Review and migration of SABRE 1 and 2 to new integrated SAFTA.
__ Participated in and contributed to ITU conferences: WRC 2003, include
WRC final acts n SAFTA, RRC planning conference for digital broadcasting.
__ Approximately 500 process equipment type approvals.
Engineering and technology: regions and monitoring
__ Enforce compliance with relative Act re. spectrum usage and stamping out
illegal spectrum usage.
__ Upgrade measuring equipment to trace and address interference:
a. Install direction-finding systems: Johannesburg, Cape Town and
Durban.
b. Install DF facilities in specialised monitoring vehicles.
__ Contribute to initial RFI measurements in support of SKA bid.
__ Project Spectra: implementing spectrum-management tools.
Engineering and technology: Key 2004/05 outcomes
__ Project Spectra (focusing on improving management, workflow and radio
frequency co-ordination and assignment processes).
__ Contribute to further RFI measurements in support of SKA bid.
__ Enforce compliance with relative Act re. Spectrum usage and stamping out
illegal spectrum usage.
__ Conduct 800 MHz sharing studies.
__ Spectrum planning and co-ordination:
a. Preparing for ITU RRC on digital broadcasting.
b. TRASA spectrum planning; L band and digital broadcasting.
__ Spectrum licencing.
__ Monitoring and interference mitigation.
__ Contributing to further RFT measurements.
__ Implementing spectrum management tools.
___ Issuing Frequency Spectrum Licences to a total of 89 000 radio
communications operators.
___ Participating in and contributing to ITU conferences.
___ Publication of an Annual Terrestrial Broadcasting Frequency Plan.
Funding model
ICASA is of the opinion that adequate funding is imperative for an effective and
independent regulatory agency as it will:
__ Allow ICASA to respond to the dynamic regulatory requirements of
Government.
__ Enable ICASA to hire and retain the right people and minimise the risk of
failure of economic regulation.
__ Prevent regulatory capture and reliance on the industry for critical regulatory
data that can influence the regulator to make decision reflecting industry
interests, and not based on independent analysis or the public interest.
__ Eliminate obstructions that would prevent ICASA from rendering its
decisions based on professional and technocratic expertise.
ICASA’s staff turnover: 2003/04
Staff turnover 10,91%
% Resignations from management level 43,33%
Management staff turnover 24,07%
ICASA: Conclusion, points for consideration and challenges
__ Community Radio: In terms of the Broadcasting Act of 1999, community
radio is currently reviewed to look at failures and successes by, amongst
others, senior international experts working with Telkom. The location of
most community radio stations in Cape Town suggests an uneven spread of
such stations.
__ Consumer protection offered by ICASA: In addition to a lot of work done
regarding road shows in educating the public in telecommunications,
broadcasting, licencing processes and improved service, ICASA studied
complaints by the public. The authority is now reconsidering its complains
procedure, with particular reference to less sophisticated users. ICASA
recently signed an agreement with Telkom regarding turn-around time and
related matters.
__ Digital Broadcasting: ICASA reported that it is not in a position to address
this challenge without a clear broadcasting policy.
__ Disability and captioning by the SABC is a matter which will be considered
by the SABC, having been tabled before by ICASA. In this regard, the
authority has published a draft code of practice, and in 2005 it will have a
public enquiry into access to programmes by people with disabilities.
__ Legal costs: The high cost of litigation is a cause of serious concern to
ICASA. In the nature of ICASA’s work, it is a common occurrence for
licencees to take the authority on review.
__ Price capturing: COA/CAM regulation could solve this problem and will
enable ICASA to investigate the cost structure of Telkom and the issue of
high tariffs.
__ Price reduction: Although competition may have brought the price of
communications down, there is currently no proof of that.
__ Rural areas: The current licences do not cover many rural areas in South
Africa. ICASA is in the process of considering a new licencing process and
strategies to address this challenge.
__ A SNO: ICASA recommended to the Government that the 51% stake in
essence be kept by Government.
___ A Youth Station for South Africa: ICASA decided not to licence any national
commercial youth radio station since the SABC is in the process of tabling
its own proposals on this matter.
E. The SABC (South A frican B roadcasting Corporation)
The SABC Board
The Board is currently in its sixth month of existence and has defined its path to
2008, which is shaped and informed by the SABC’s role and social
responsibilities in terms of the Broadcasting and IBA Acts and expounded upon
in its editorial policies. The challenge facing the new SABC Board is to
consolidate the gains accumulated over the past 10 years and to steer the SABC
along its development path to 2008.
The goals of the SABC Board, a synopsis
__ Ensure the SABC promotes democracy, non-racism, nation-building and
empowerment through innovative programming that is informative,
entertaining and educative in all official languages.
__ Align the SABC with the broadcasting charter, the SABC’s objectives as set
out in the Broadcasting Act and the editorial policies.
__ Create a financially sound corporation built on a sustainable business model
within a specified timeframe that enables it to fulfil its mandate.
__ Revitalise the Corporation, particularly the news department, by making it s
place of preferred employment and by attracting, retaining and nurturing the
best available talent in South Africa.
__ Ensure full statutory and regulatory compliance by all divisions of the
broadcaster.
__ Ensure appropriate employment equity and black economic empowerment
policies.
__ Create an SABC that enjoys the support and respect of its shareholder,
viewers, listeners and other stakeholders.
__ Ensure compelling, professional and authoritative news and current affairs
programming.
__ Ensure that the SABC puts into place innovative technology platforms and
infrastucture that will enable it to deliver on its mandate.
___ Conduct an evaluation and monitor the extent to which its activities are in
line with the provisions of the Broadcasting Act and its editorial policies.
___ Create a corporation that delivers interesting, educative and dynamic
programming in all of South Africa’s official languages.
___ Sign off on policy documents in terms of the Broadcasting Act.
The SABC’s broad corporate objectives
__ In terms of content, to deliver the best content to fulfil the SABC’s mandate
in the most cost-effective way to maximise audiences and revenues.
__ In terms of people, to attract, develop and retain the best creative and other
talent.
__ In terms of technology, to put in place the appropriate technology
infrastructure to deliver on the SABC’s objectives.
__ In terms of finance, to ensure effective and efficient utilization of resources,
a financially sustainable corporation, and to put into place world-class
systems and processes.
__ In terms of corporate reputation, to be the most admired media brand in
South Africa.
The SABC identified the following four big areas where shareholder funding
support is request in order to achieve the public broadcaster’s and national
objectives
__ Technology plan.
__ Regional television.
__ Education.
__ SABC Africa.
SABC: an overview of its technology division
__ Providing broadcasting and non-broadcast technology solutions, services
and infrastructure for its content divisions.
__ The division incorporates the following five business units: Air Time, Henley
TV Facilities, Technical Liaison, Logistical Services, Engineering Services
and Broadcast Information Technology.
__ The SABC reported an undercapitalisation of the aforementioned areas in
recent years.
__ Key challenges include the migration to digital technologies.
__ In the 2002/03 financial years, a comprehensive technology strategy was
formulated, the main focus of which was an assessment of the current state
of technology (within the SABC), defining the future business and broadcast
needs of the SABC in a digital era, and technology solutions.
__ In terms of the business IT strategy identified, interventions in the SABC’s
core business, content sales and scheduling, and supporting business
activities such as finance, client-facing business units – corporate and
regulatory.
__ The aforementioned resulted in a three-horizon prioritised investment:
a. Horizon 1: Tactical priority areas (the financial system, data
warehousing and digital content production solutions.
b. Horizon 2: Similar focus to the aforementioned, but over a the
longer term, viz. redesigning broadcast content workflows,
proceeding with middleware installation, scheduling systems and
ERP.
c. Horizon 3: Technological areas of strategic importance to the
SABC’s of ultimately moving to a completely digital technological
infrastructure.
Some 2004/05 financial year technology objectives
__ Content sales and scheduling system.
__ Digital news production system.
__ Finance and HR systems.
__ Consolidation of online content publishing.
__ Consumer-relationship management.
__ The shareholder was requested to provide R340 million to fund capex in
support of achieving the technology plan goals and objectives.
__ The aforementioned strategy is continuously monitored by the board, and
was requested to prepare a detailed funding plan before final approvals are
obtained.
The SABC’s education mandate
In terms of this mandate, the public service provided by the SABC must include
educational programming – curriculum-based as well as informal. Radio and
television programmes, therefore, were produced in the following genres:
__ Early childhood development.
__ Curriculum support.
__ Adult public education.
Radio and television production, a synopsis
__ During the period March 2003 to January 2004, over 119 000 minutes of
educational television programming was broadcasted in a variety of
timeslots across the SABC’s terrestrial channels.
__ The aforementioned represents an increase of 20% over the same period of
the previous year, with 94% of the programmes produced locally.
__ Original television programming was produced in African languages.
__ Dubbing of local programmes and foreign acquisitions into a number of
African languages ensured output in all official languages.
__ Radio’s output remained constant at 150 000 minutes of educational
programming in all official languages.
Tuesday, 24 August 2004] 559
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
__ In order to achieve its future objectives, the SABC has requested support
from the shareholder to the amount of R47 million.
__ The SABC merged its two pay channels, SABC Africa and Africa-2-Africa in
April 2003 – relaunching these as a single information and entertainment
channel on the DSTV platform.
__ SABC Africa aims to provide and project a positive and modern image of
Africa and in the process to assist in promoting the NEPAD ideals.
__ The SABC reported funding as its main challenge and that improved
delivery will be possible if there are integrated strategies and efforts within
and beyond the SABC.
___ The SABC plans to creatively look at PPP relationships, increasing funding
from commercial sources and partnering with Government to secure the
necessary funds.
SABC: Points raised by members of the committee
__ Accessibility of radio and television broadcasting poses a particular
challenge to the SABC.
__ Advertising: Although advertising offers a viable source of income to the
SABC and advertising in English proves profitable, steps could be taken to
ensure that products are advertised in African languages as well.
__ Cultural sensitivity: In its broadcasting, the SABC should at all times display
cultural sensitivity. It is not clear whether the corporation has a policy in
place on this topic.
__ Disability and captioning: Although there has been an increase in subtitling
on television, the SABC reports that currently it does not have a policy in
place to address this matter.
__ Editorial policy: Generally speaking the SABC’s editorial policy makes
provision for all SABC editorial staff and requires from staff to fully
understand and implement the corporation’s editorial policy. The policy
places the emphasis on widening democracy and to be inclusive of all
cultures and realities in South Africa. The current board believes that its
editorial policy adheres to the principles of dignity of all South Africans in the
corporation’s programming. It would not like to be a mere organ for sectoral
interest and, consequently, would like to promote democracy, non-racialism
and nationalism in an entertaining fashion.
__ Transformed technology base: An amount of approximately R1,2 billion is
required by the corporation for its transformed technology base.
F. The USA (Un iversa l Service Agency)
The USA’s core programmes include:
__ Telecentres.
__ E-schools cyberlabs.
__ Capacity-building.
__ Research and evaluation.
__ Infrastructure development and deployment.
__ The ICT awareness programme.
The USA’s facilities
Province Telecentres MPCCs Cyberlabs Total
Northern Cape 3 1 11 15
Free State 6 1 10 17
Eastern Cape 8 4 18 30
Kwa-Zulu Natal 7 5 30 42
Limpopo 12 5 17 34
Mpumalanga 7 3 19 29
Gauteng 8 2 4 14
North West 7 2 14 23
Western Cape 2 0 6 8
60 23 129 212
The USA’s and the USF’s deliverables
__ The deployment of 50 new e-school cyberlabs in the nodal points.
__ Addressing the connectivity and content of the existing 200 e-school
cyberlabs.
__ Rolling out 35 telecentres in MPCCs.
__ Rehabilitating the existing telecentres with regard to content and services.
__ Researching the provision of universal service and universal access to ICT
in South Africa.
__ Subsidising SMMEs and co-operatives.
__ Focusing on the 2004 Universal Access and Service National Conference.
The USA’s capacity-building initiatives include:
__ Establishment of the Telecentre Association of South Africa (TASA)
__ Skills and competency of employers.
__ Staff training.
__ Training of 100 managers and operators of telecentres in ICT and business
management.
The USA presented the following budget for the current financial year:
Salaries and wages 9 452 465
Administrative expenditure 3 055 795
Inventory 26 100
Equipment 682 776
Land building 834 498
Professional and special services 1 916 466
Total 16 384 000
USA: Conclusion, points for consideration and challenges
__ MPCCs. The Agency will work closely with the Government Communication
and Information System (GCIS) in setting up telecentres and MPCCs.
__ If telecentres are put up, the USA advertises the services of such centres
and acts as a facilitator and a catalyst.
__ While some telecentres are currently functioning independently, once they
have been taken over by the local communities, they offer Internet
connection 24 hours a day; other telecentres must, however, still be
subsidised.
__ The USA is currently faced with the financial sustainability of some
telecentres.
__ Many of the USA’s telecentre initiatives will be in partnership with Sentech
(providing V-techs in schools), with the assistance of ICASA. These will be
supported by the provision of computers by the USA.
__ The relative brief lifespan of computer equipment (particularly for the
provision of Internet connectivity) is of concern to the USA. While various
service providers have provided computers to schools, they never revisited
the upgrading of such equipment.
__ The USA needs to liaise with South Africans on a grass-roots level in order
to determine the impact of its ICT initiatives.
__ Currently, the USA does not have enough contact centres; members of
Parliament could assist in reaching-out initiatives in order to determine areas
of critical need.
__ The USA’s R1 million, budgeted for its mass awareness of ICTs, should
enable it to take the lead in working together with the cellular industry, the
Department of Education, local government structures, Telkom and the
portfolio committee in achieving universal access.
G. Telkom S .A. L td.
Telkom’s strategic focus
__ Customer growth and retention.
__ Operational efficiencies and innovation.
__ Development of the market place.
Economic growth and sustainability
Employment equity:
__ Black employees: 56%.
__ Female employees: 27%.
__ Employees with disabilities: 1%.
Utilities liaison forums:
To address unnecessary and costly damages to the underground infrastructure.
Regulatory compliance:
__ Public Finance Management Act.
__ Employment Equity Act.
__ Electronic Communications and Transactions Act.
__ Telecommunications Act.
__ Spatial Data Infrastructure Act.
__ Regulation of Interception of Communications and the Provision of
Communications Related Information Act.
__ Environmental legislation.
__ Municipal Property Rates Act.
__ Films and Publications Amendment Bill.
___ Convergence Draft Bill
Telkom managing its challenges
Telkom’s regulatory update
__ The SNO has not yet been licenced.
__ Four under-serviced area licences were approved by the Minister.
__ Tariff regulations.
__ COA/CAM: accounts are to be presented in June 2004 on historic cost basis
Tuesday, 24 August 2004] 563
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
Telkom’s legal update
__ Telcordia:
a. Telkom won review application.
b. Telcordia’s appeal was rejected.
c. Arbitration to recommence in South Africa, timing not yet known.
__ Least-cost routing:
a. Telkom lost case.
b. Filed appeal, awaiting court date.
__ Competition Commission:
a. Filed application to set aside Commission referral to Tribunal.
Broad-based Black Economic Empowerment, BEE
__ Group BEE spend of approximately R5 billion in 2003/04; R24 billion spent
since 1997, approximately 18% with black-owned SMMEs (Telkom only).
__ Telkom named ‘most empowered company in SA’ in the Financial
Mail/Empowerdex survey of 200 listed companies.
Social sustainability
__ On the strength of its triple bottom-line reporting, Telkom qualified for the
Social Responsibility Index of the JSE Securities Exchange.
__ Telkom rated among the top two companies in SA in community upliftment –
Sunday Times/Markinor Top Brand survey, 2003.
__ Telkom’s SHE management system awarded international certification:
ISO14001 and OHASAS 18001.
__ R14,6 million invested in SHE during 2003/04, including:
a. Training for 14 300 employees.
b. Voluntary, confidential medical screening.
c. Integrated health profiling.
__ HIV/AIDS prevalence at 9,6%, compared to the SA average of 26,5%,
according to an independent actuarial survey.
__ Response programme being strengthened through treatment programmes,
support and care, peer education and voluntary counseling.
Skills development
__ Telkom is the largest levy-payer in the ICT sector.
__ R390 million for people development in 2003/04, equating to 8,3 training
days per employee.
__ Two learnerships implemented with Isett Seta for call centre and project
management skills.
564 [Tuesday, 24 August 2004
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
Innovation
__ A key partner in industry centre-of-excellence research programme:
a. R175 million for research since 1997.
b. 350 post graduate students involved.
c. Telkom funding for 73 full-time research students.
Job creation
__ Telkom boasts the country’s largest call centres and is stimulating fixed-line
traffic through its 14 international call-centre customers.
__ SKA Project: Telkom supports South Africa’s bid to host the Square
Kilometre Array telescope.
Supporting Government initiatives
__ NEPAD initiative.
__ USALs.
__ ICT Charter.
__ 2010 Bid.
Telkom’s Data Product Adjustments
Telkom reported an average data product increase of 1%. These are broken
down into the following key data products:
Diginet increases by 5,3%
Diginet Plus decreases by 3%
Megaline increases by 4,8%
Megaline Plus no increase
ATM Express no increase
IPLC (cable) decreases by 9,3%
IPLC (satellite) decreases by 7,8%
VIP Dial/VIP Link increases by 5%
Frame Express no increase
Telkom’s annual results, a synopsis
__ The review period is Telkom’s first as a listed company.
__ Headline earnings per share increased by 175% to R8,64.
__ Operating free cash flow increased from approximately R4 billion in 2003 to
R9 billion during the review period.
__ Telkom’s group operating revenue increased by 8,8% to approximately
R40,8 million.
Tuesday, 24 August 2004] 565
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
__ Telkom’s cash from operating activities increased by 42% to approximately
R13,9 million.
Employment equity
With the implementation of affirmative action, Telkom recorded the following staff
complement (1 October 1993):
Black 46% (African 30%, Coloured 13%, Indian 3%).
Women 19% of Telkom’s total employees.
Telkom’s current staff complement:
Black (operational) 62%
Female (operational) 29%
Black (supervising) 41%
Female (supervising) 22%
Black (management) 35%
Disabled 1%
Telkom: Points raised by members of the committee
__ Profitability is the result of the following two elements: revenue and cost, and
the difference between revenue and cost. Telkom’s 4,6% profit increase was
the result of a successful drive and focus on improving its efficiency, paying
back debt, improving its management systems and a R34 billion investment
in its communications network. Telkom is subject to a price-control regime
by means of ICASA regulation. ICASA did start the process of reviewing
Telkom’s tariff regime, which is to be based on reasonable economic
considerations. Telkom’s profitability does not purely result from price
increases.
__ Regulation of access by Telkom to submarine cables is required since this is
still unregulated.
__ Telkom’s retrenchment rate: Telkom reports that it is involved in the
following three tiers of employment creation: (a) a creative plan focusing on
training and re-training, (b) investment through broad-based BEE, and (c)
making a contribution to the industry and the communications sector.
Telkom partly focuses on retraining its staff and assisting them in becoming
involved in related communications sectors. It reported that since 1997, R24
billion was spent on this, with an 18% investment in black-owned SMMEs.
__ Does the South African communications landscape offer sufficient room for
a SNO? Telkom reports that the answer to the aforementioned question is to
be found in the market place. When mobile communications were
introduced in 1994, initially half a million potential customers were targeted.
This figure has now grown to between 15 and 19 million. In this context,
Telkom forecasts a bright future for the SNO.
566 [Tuesday, 24 August 2004
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
H. Sentech
Sentech supports the position of the DoC as expressed during their presentation.
To Sentech -
__ Digitisation is key.
__ Access is paramount.
__ The lifting of specific restrictions is required.
Digitisation
Digital Terrestrial Television (DTT) is a key component of digitisation for South
Africa:
__ Digital relates to the way programmes are processed and transmitted.
__ Multiple channels – the broadcaster owns the channel, while the signal
distributor owns the frequency.
__ Set-top box/decoder.
The advantages of DTT
__ Efficient use of frequency spectrum (more broadcasters can be licenced).
__ Lower transmission costs (saving to broadcasters).
__ Industry growth through local receiver manufacturing (employment creation).
__ Multiple language channel capability (cultural diversity).
__ Ease of reception, simple installation and operation.
__ Portable and mobile compatible.
__ Enhanced service offerings such as e-government, adult education and
health services.
__ Lower transmitter power operation per TV service.
__ No foreign control by satellite operators (dollar-based costs).
___ Regional TV a strong driver (roll-out coupled to additional services as well
as increased number of broadcasters).
___ Universal service targets comparatively easier to achieve for public
broadcaster.
___ Variety of programming and enhanced multimedia offering such as EPG,
news, games, etc.
___ Delivery mechanism for distance education and e-Government.
___ Services can be encrypted – licence fee collection can be enhanced.
___ International equipment manufacturers transition to DTT (will affect future
analogue equipment and spares availability; Sentech’s current broadcasting
network is old, analogue and must be replaced).
___ Interactive potential (growth of the industry, bridging the digital divide).
Tuesday, 24 August 2004] 567
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
Sentech proposes the following three-phase roll-out of DTT to South Africa’s
approximately 9 million households of which approximately 7 million has
television
__ Since Johannesburg has an existing test site, DTT should first be made
available in that city, together with 50% of non-metropolitan areas.
__ The remaining 50% of non-metropolitan areas.
__ South Africa’s metropoles.
Note: Metropoles cover approximately 20 million viewers, while non-metropolitan
areas cover an estimated 24 million viewers.
Sentech anticipates the cost structure of DTT roll-out and the cost of a regional
network to be as follows
__ 7 million set-top boxes to be acquired at a cost of R468 per box.
__ 7 million antennae at R100 per antenna (taking into consideration that
viewers may opt to use their existing antennae) – at a total cost of R3,98
billion.
__ A national transmitter network at a total cost of R268 million.
__ Transmitters at a cost of R153 million.
__ Decoders/antennae at a cost of R2,27 billion.
The following is required to make digitisation happen
A commitment from policy makers:
__ A national digitisation policy.
__ A migration policy (support for viewers in respect of set-top boxes)
Radio coverage
__ Radio coverage everywhere in South Africa.
__ Not all stations are received everywhere, but every citizen can listen to the
radio.
The MyWireless Service
__ Always on access.
__ Three options (128, 256 or 512 kb/s).
__ No cap on data transfer.
__ Portable at no extra charge.
__ Self-installed – plug and play.
__ E-mail account included in monthly price.
568 [Tuesday, 24 August 2004
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
Lifting restrictions
__ Increased competitiveness (managed liberalisation still intact).
__ Reduced prices for communications customers (increased competitiveness
of all industries).
__ Leveling the playing field.
What restrictions need to be lifted?
Carrier of carriers licence:
__ Sentech should be entitled to terminate international services to end-users.
__ Amend section 1 (definition of Carrier of Carriers Service).
__ Access to submarine cables.
__ USALs.
Restrictions to be lifted for multimedia:
__ Internationally, multimedia communications encompass all services,
including voice.
__ Sentech’s network is voice capable – one cannot purchase equipment
because it is voice restricted.
__ Customers will use multimedia network for voice – impossible to police.
__ Sentech should be entitled to carry voice.
__ Enable Sentech to carry voice services to the benefit of consumers by:
a. Amending the definition of multimedia services in section 1 of the
Telecommunications Act.
b. Amending or deleting sections 32C(8), 36A(h)(vi).
c. Facilities to VANs.
Other restrictions to be lifted
__ Amend section 30A and 30B of the Act (to enable Sentech to access 1800
Mhz and 3G spectrum).
__ Amend sections 36A and 36B of the Act, which will enable Sentech to
provide:
a. Circuits for voice-over IP.
b. Facilities required for private telecommunication networks.
c. Fixed links for mobiles and WBS.
d. Facilities for interconnection with USALs.
e. Facilities for VANs.
f. Facilities for fixed-mobile services in 1800Mhz band.
Tuesday, 24 August 2004] 569
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
Sentech: Points raised by members of the committee
__ Broadcasting: In many parts of our country there is either no sign or a weak
sign. It should be noted that while Sentech may be responsible for installing
transmitters in bad reception areas, ICASA must approve the licence
application for such installations, which places the emphasis on the need for
a policy framework regarding digitisation.
__ Digital and employment creation pose a particular challenge to Sentech. In
order to fulfil its mandate, Sentech needs to be able to tap its local skills
base. As part of Sentech’s social responsibility, training in all of South
Africa’s centres is to be prioritised, especially because of the migration of
skills between Cape Town, Durban and Johannesburg.
__ Corporations such as Sentech and Telkom could consider a partnership
approach to retain the migration of skills to develop the local provincial
economies.
__ The manufacturing of decoders in South Africa will be done jointly with a
Korean company, which represents significant progress in the local
manufacturing industry, together with much-needed expertise.
__ Provincial and local broadcasting challenges: Sentech is becoming
increasingly involved in provincial and local government broadcasting
challenges. It now talks to members of that tier of government about
programmes and its mandate on a local level.
__ Digitisation is fast becoming one of Sentech’s major challenges. Sentech
has been active in this field for some time. A task team advised the Minister.
Cabinet adopted its recommendations, which was followed by a further
analysis. Digital migration should be finalised by 2006, at an estimated cost
of R45 billion spread over a period of 20 years. Despite digitisation,
analogue and digital broadcasting have to co-exist until the whole of South
Africa becomes digital. In the meantime, both analogue and digital platforms
must be accommodated, which, at this point, doubles the cost during the
cross-over process. The cost implication is, therefore, that the price of
broadcasting is not lowered since broadcasters offer two services. The 20-
year period is seen as a process of gradual migration in order to allow
particularly the African continent to digitise. At the same time, a balance
must be struck between the needs of rural and urban areas. Clients in rural
areas cannot be left with analogue platforms only.
__ Outdated transmitters: Some of the SABC’s transmitters are becoming so
outdated that they can no longer be repaired since parts for those are not
available, which means that they have to be manufactured locally.
570 [Tuesday, 24 August 2004
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004
A synopsis of points raised by members of the
Ad-hoc Portfolio Committee on Communications
A. South Africa’s current communications sector operates within the country’s first and
second economies. The cost of connecting all South Africans is increasingly
becoming the communications sector’s greatest challenge. All role-players in the
communications sector and industry must take cognisance, therefore, of providing
connectivity to middle-class, working class, and poor South Africans.
B. A SNO in South Africa could play a pivotal role in creating healthy and meaningful
competition in the communications sector, with particular emphasis on affordability.
C. Price-structuring in the telecommunications sector could assist in meeting the
Government’s mandate of providing affordable communications to all South Africans
and bridging the digital divide, not only within the borders of South Africa, but also
throughout the continent of Africa and the world.
D. The transformation of South Africa’s communications sector may result in the lifting
of unrealistic restrictions. This, in turn, may result in either legislative amendments or
removing restrictive legislation from the Statute Book.
E. The redrafting of South Africa’s Convergence Bill is a matter of urgency. It is
envisaged that this legislation will be presented to Cabinet in the last quarter of this
year and subsequently to the Ad-hoc Portfolio Committee on Communications.
F. Multi-purpose Community Centres and Public Information Terminals are
integral parts of South Africa’s ICT roll-out and infrastructure.
G. Radio reception (with particular reference to our country’s language groups) and
television reception is an ongoing challenge to South Africa’s communications
sector.
H. Digital broadcasting and universal access are becoming South Africa’s main
challenges in providing access to communications for all its citizens. Since South
Africa’s current broadcasting infrastructure is ageing, digitisation is seen as the only
solution to 21st-century broadcasting challenges. A clear broadcasting policy would
assist this process.
Tuesday, 24 August 2004] 571
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS NO 52—2004